Tests
I prefer use the results from others players to prove my tactics.
Thank you very much for your tests!
I'm waiting for you!
Mantorras77's Tactic Testing League
Introduction:
Hey everyone. I did a few of these Tactic Tests last year but would post the results in the individual tactic threads themselves. This year I decided to start my own thread just to be able keep it organized and easily track and compare results. Ive been an FM'r since the CM days and I want to contribute to the community in any way I can so this is it.
Now I know what you're all thinking "Not another tactic testing thread!!". A_ilfandy does a great job at what he does over on his tactic testing thread and he works hard at it. If you haven't checked it out please do so here.
The method of testing i'm using is an 8-team custom league where I take 1 tactic, assign it to one of the 8 custom teams all of equal value, play a season with it and see how it stacks up against the cpu. The key thing is to eliminate as many variables as possible and that is why every team is exactly identical from the Staff all the way down to the Training Facilities. This way it really focusses in the tactic itself. This method was created and used by the legend Mr. Langvatn last year in his own tactics thread. So all credit goes to him on this. I'm very thankfull that he shared it with me.
Submit Your Tactic:
- PM me with the words "TTL SUBMISSION" in the Title Field. (easier for me to track this way)
- Include the direct link to your Tactic you want me to test.
- Include the direct link to your thread.
ALSO
- I will be on the lookout for exciting tactics out there in the FM world and testing them as well.
How I Test:
- Each game is played at the Tactic Testing Stadium vs cpu teams of equal value
- I make sure every tactic is fully fluid before the start of the season
- I remove injuries and make morale Superb before each game to remove these variables
- I play the games on Key Highlights
- I only substitute a player if the game makes me do it
- All Team Talks are done by the *** Man.(*** Man has a Motivating of 18)
- All OI's are done by the *** Man (If applicable) (*** Man has a Tactical Knowledge of 18)
- Meet your Player's (The Outfielder and the Goalie) (200 CA for ea)
Results:
- I will post all final results to the table below.
- I will create an individual post for each tactic.
- A quality tactic will be able to hit at least 60 points in the TTL
- All tactics are downloadable by clicking on them in the table below
- If you enjoy the tactic please show the author some love by posting it on their thread
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
FM14 TTL TABLE (Patch 14.1.3)
DISCLAIMER: Your individual results will vary with each tactic. This means that because a tactic does good or bad on this test doesn't mean you'll experience the same results. This method isn't perfect but it's a great baseline.
a_ilfandy's Huge Tactics Testing Project (FM 2014)
ROUND 4
Patch: 14.1.3
Mode: Normal
Competition: World Super League
Progress: COMPLETED!
Tactics entry:
Super League A
BARCELONA: Iamauser (3 - Lets Score Goals)
CHELSEA: Krunccrni (253 overlord)
BAYERN: Miles (Dullnut Counter Att)
MAN CITY: Seanhrfc (Arrigo Sacchi 4-4-2 V2)
Super League B
JUVENTUS: Shagunner (1ATK_ Diamond No Defence)
MAN UNITED: StueyRob (ForeverFM14)
PARIS SG: Wampley (Wee Free Men Final)
REAL MADRID: Zero Sea (V2 4231L Rage)
Leagues:
Cup:
Playoff:
Selected Playoff Matches:
List of Winners:
- League A: Krunccrni
- League B: Zero Sea
- Best offence: Krunccrni
- Best defence: Seanhrfc
- Cup: Krunccrni
- Playoff: Zero Sea
Speacial Achievements:
- We have a double-double!
- Krunccrni won League A and the Cup.
- Zero Sea won League B and the Playoffs.
a_ilfandy's Huge Tactics Testing Project (FM 2014)
ROUND 6
Patch: 14.1.3
Mode: Normal
Competition: Skrill Super League
Progress: COMPLETED!
Tactics entry:
Skrill League A
CHESTER: Dutchbrit (4-1-2-1-2 Niche)
GATESHEAD: Jonathansmith (352 D-WING)
GRIMSBY: Julian (4-1-2-2-1_PWNAGE)
LUTON: Macey (Simple_Pressing)
Skrill League B
ALDERSHOT: Richie Sousa (Richie's 4-3-2-1)
FOREST GREEN: Spiattalo (Total Football)
KIDDERMINSTER: Tanveer (3-4-2-1 liverpool)
WREXHAM: Zero Sea (V3 424R Rage)
Leagues:
Cup:
Playoff:
Selected Playoff Matches:
List of Winners:
- League A: Julian
- League B: Zero Sea
- Best offence: Zero Sea
- Best defence: Julian
- Cup: Zero Sea
- Playoff: Macey
Special Achievements:
- Zero Sea won both League B and the Cup.
Note:
- Post #2 (Table of the Hall of Fame) has been updated!
I prefer use the results from others players to prove my tactics.
Thank you very much for your tests!
I'm waiting for you!
Mantorras77's Tactic Testing League
Introduction:
Hey everyone. I did a few of these Tactic Tests last year but would post the results in the individual tactic threads themselves. This year I decided to start my own thread just to be able keep it organized and easily track and compare results. Ive been an FM'r since the CM days and I want to contribute to the community in any way I can so this is it.
Now I know what you're all thinking "Not another tactic testing thread!!". A_ilfandy does a great job at what he does over on his tactic testing thread and he works hard at it. If you haven't checked it out please do so here.
The method of testing i'm using is an 8-team custom league where I take 1 tactic, assign it to one of the 8 custom teams all of equal value, play a season with it and see how it stacks up against the cpu. The key thing is to eliminate as many variables as possible and that is why every team is exactly identical from the Staff all the way down to the Training Facilities. This way it really focusses in the tactic itself. This method was created and used by the legend Mr. Langvatn last year in his own tactics thread. So all credit goes to him on this. I'm very thankfull that he shared it with me.
Submit Your Tactic:
- PM me with the words "TTL SUBMISSION" in the Title Field. (easier for me to track this way)
- Include the direct link to your Tactic you want me to test.
- Include the direct link to your thread.
ALSO
- I will be on the lookout for exciting tactics out there in the FM world and testing them as well.
How I Test:
- Each game is played at the Tactic Testing Stadium vs cpu teams of equal value
- I make sure every tactic is fully fluid before the start of the season
- I remove injuries and make morale Superb before each game to remove these variables
- I play the games on Key Highlights
- I only substitute a player if the game makes me do it
- All Team Talks are done by the *** Man.(*** Man has a Motivating of 18)
- All OI's are done by the *** Man (If applicable) (*** Man has a Tactical Knowledge of 18)
- Meet your Player's (The Outfielder and the Goalie) (200 CA for ea)
Results:
- I will post all final results to the table below.
- I will create an individual post for each tactic.
- A quality tactic will be able to hit at least 60 points in the TTL
- All tactics are downloadable by clicking on them in the table below
- If you enjoy the tactic please show the author some love by posting it on their thread
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
FM14 TTL TABLE (Patch 14.1.3)
Tactic | W | D | L | PTS | GF | GA | GD |
Zero Sea's Rage 100℃ Real 343R (v3)* | 22 | 3 | 3 | 69 | 57 | 18 | +39 |
Fluid 523 Attack by ???* | 20 | 6 | 2 | 66 | 54 | 18 | +36 |
???'s Barcelona | 21 | 3 | 4 | 66 | 55 | 22 | +33 |
The Truly TIKI-TAKA - by ??? | 18 | 8 | 2 | 62 | 58 | 23 | +35 |
??? best tactic for FM14 | 19 | 4 | 5 | 61 | 60 | 24 | +36 |
???'s 4-4-2 for FM14 (v2) | 18 | 6 | 4 | 60 | 54 | 18 | +36 |
???'s Untouchable 4-5-1 | 19 | 3 | 6 | 60 | 40 | 18 | +22 |
Different 451 Tactic with Success (???) | 17 | 7 | 4 | 58 | 37 | 17 | +20 |
???'s Pressure Balanced | 14 | 8 | 6 | 50 | 50 | 28 | +22 |
4141 ??? Walking Dead 14.1.3* | 12 | 5 | 11 | 41 | 35 | 27 | +8 |
DISCLAIMER: Your individual results will vary with each tactic. This means that because a tactic does good or bad on this test doesn't mean you'll experience the same results. This method isn't perfect but it's a great baseline.
a_ilfandy's Huge Tactics Testing Project (FM 2014)
ROUND 4
Patch: 14.1.3
Mode: Normal
Competition: World Super League
Progress: COMPLETED!
Tactics entry:
Super League A
BARCELONA: Iamauser (3 - Lets Score Goals)
CHELSEA: Krunccrni (253 overlord)
BAYERN: Miles (Dullnut Counter Att)
MAN CITY: Seanhrfc (Arrigo Sacchi 4-4-2 V2)
Super League B
JUVENTUS: Shagunner (1ATK_ Diamond No Defence)
MAN UNITED: StueyRob (ForeverFM14)
PARIS SG: Wampley (Wee Free Men Final)
REAL MADRID: Zero Sea (V2 4231L Rage)
Leagues:
Cup:
Playoff:
Selected Playoff Matches:
List of Winners:
- League A: Krunccrni
- League B: Zero Sea
- Best offence: Krunccrni
- Best defence: Seanhrfc
- Cup: Krunccrni
- Playoff: Zero Sea
Speacial Achievements:
- We have a double-double!
- Krunccrni won League A and the Cup.
- Zero Sea won League B and the Playoffs.
a_ilfandy's Huge Tactics Testing Project (FM 2014)
ROUND 6
Patch: 14.1.3
Mode: Normal
Competition: Skrill Super League
Progress: COMPLETED!
Tactics entry:
Skrill League A
CHESTER: Dutchbrit (4-1-2-1-2 Niche)
GATESHEAD: Jonathansmith (352 D-WING)
GRIMSBY: Julian (4-1-2-2-1_PWNAGE)
LUTON: Macey (Simple_Pressing)
Skrill League B
ALDERSHOT: Richie Sousa (Richie's 4-3-2-1)
FOREST GREEN: Spiattalo (Total Football)
KIDDERMINSTER: Tanveer (3-4-2-1 liverpool)
WREXHAM: Zero Sea (V3 424R Rage)
Leagues:
Cup:
Playoff:
Selected Playoff Matches:
List of Winners:
- League A: Julian
- League B: Zero Sea
- Best offence: Zero Sea
- Best defence: Julian
- Cup: Zero Sea
- Playoff: Macey
Special Achievements:
- Zero Sea won both League B and the Cup.
Note:
- Post #2 (Table of the Hall of Fame) has been updated!
Last edited: