My Huge Tactics Testing Project (FM 2014)

a_ilfandy

Member
Joined
Nov 2, 2009
Messages
1,275
Reaction score
0
Points
36
Introduction:

Well guys, My Huge Tactics Testing Project is back! This one will be the fourth yearly project in a row.
In case you haven't heard about it, then you should take a look on how its been done in the previous FM versions.

FM 13: http://www.fm-base.co.uk/forum/foot...-testing-project-football-manager-2013-a.html
FM 12: http://www.fm-base.co.uk/forum/foot...-testing-project-football-manager-2012-a.html
FM 11: http://www.fm-base.co.uk/forum/foot...ng/78624-my-huge-tactics-testing-project.html

PS: I thank all of you for the support over the years. It kept me motivated..

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Objectives:

Now, this year's project is no different, its all about finding out the most reliable PLUG-N-PLAY tactics for the BIG teams. Against popular beliefs, I always believe that we can still be VERY successful in this game even if we play it in a plug-n-play fashion. As long as we have (1) a title challenging squad and (2) a very consistent tactic.

That's why I'm looking for a 'one for all' tactic. A tactic that is reliable for both home/away games, against big/small teams, and efficient in any league. A tactic that can win us trophies without using any shout, OP, or any other 'individual based' interventions. I know, there is no such 'wonder' or 'exploit' tactics in recent FMs. But there are always few standout tactics that are very reliable and consistent. That's what I'm looking for!

Beforehand, I would like to remind everyone that this project is not meant to degrade any well-known tactic out there. Some popular tactics may struggle in this test, NOT because they are not good, simply because not all tactics will work in a plug-n-play style of playing.

This is a quantitative, result-oriented, and statistical project. Therefore, don't ask me any in-depth question, such as, strength/weakness of a tactic. Such questions will be directed to the original creator/thread instead.

Also, my sincere in-advanced apologies to the tactic creators for including your creation without proper permission. I normally tested hundreds of tactics in each year, and waiting permission for every tactic is very time consuming. My bad..

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

Methodologies:

Mode: Normal (not classic)
Transfer: I cancelled the loans, injuries and suspensions.
Length: full season
Competitions: 1 league, 1 cup, 1 Champ playoffs
Teams: Top clubs from various top leagues
Match day: Watch all games, no instant result
Team selection: Quick pick
Training/match preparation/team talk: Ast. Manager
Pitch size: Standard
Highlight: Only commentary (fastest speed)
Intervention: No shouts or OP
Substitution: Only in case of injury or red card

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

Your contributions:

You are all very welcome to suggest any tactic to be tested in this project. Though I'll start by testing the more recognized ones. I'm very open with the idea of testing tactics which cant be found in this site, so be my guest.

Please keep your comments and discussions civilized. Any personal differences should be settled somewhere else.

Just like any other thread in any type of forum, my thread also requires attention. So, a once in a while thumbs up is always good for the motivation. ;)

So lets start the project then...

Notes:
- You may check the summary of ALL rounds in POST #2
- You may also check the latest update for the current round on POST #3

Urgent note, if any of you know-how-to and willing to make me an 'all equal teams' league database, then I'll be happy to use it for this project. In my last few attempts, it ended as an unplayable database or in-game crashes. So the best thing I can do right now is to use the original big teams.
 
Last edited:
SUMMARY OF ALL ROUNDS:


===================TABLE OF THE HALL OF FAME======================


Round

League_A

League_B

Cup

Playoff

Offence

Defence

Summary
Pre-testing

Callamity
******
Andrich
Seanhrfc
Callamity
******
Post #22
Round 1

Nezza
Veez
Nezza
Xenon
Veez
Veez
Post #46
Round 2

Dennis
Tomfmlfc
Tomfmlfc
Eagleheart
Dennis
Dennis
Post #75
Round 3
Jeid
Michael
Kun
Kun
Jeid
Kun
Post #105
Round 4
Krunccrni
Zero Sea
Krunccrni
Zero Sea
Krunccrni
Seanhrfc
Post #122
Round 5
HalaMadrid
Niclas
HalaMadrid
Niclas
Nsickboy
Niclas
Post #152
Round 6
Julian
Zero Sea
Zero Sea
Macey
Zero Sea
Julian
Post #168
Round 7LordofavpVoduSilasLucasVoduLordofavpPost #186
The Best

Dennis

Veez

Andrich

Xenon

Veez

Dennis

Above

 
Last edited:
LATEST RESULTS UPDATE!!!


FINAL RESULTS! (Skrill League Teams)

ROUND 7
Patch: 14.1.3
Mode: Normal
Competition: Skrill Super League
Progress: COMPLETED!
Tactics entry:

Skrill League A
CHESTER: Aretikz (3-5-2_unic_firdaus_1)
GATESHEAD: Bozica (4-2-2-2_unsym_61809)
GRIMSBY: Lordofavp (SkeetSkeet)
LUTON: Lucas (4-2-4_tactic_v1_1)

Skrill League B
ALDERSHOT: Rabbelsnake (3-5-2_false_madrid_1)
FOREST GREEN: RobertoMancini (4-2-3-1 cuper)
KIDDERMINSTER: Silas (tiki-taka_58412)
WREXHAM: Vodu (4141_walking_dead)

Leagues:


Cup:


Playoff:


Selected Playoff Matches:


List of Winners:
- League A: Lordofavp
- League B: Vodu
- Best offence: Vodu
- Best defence: Lordofavp
- Cup: Silas
- Playoff: Lucas
 
Last edited:
Great to see you back with the testing - looking forward to following you.
 
Results Update (Pre-testing)

Patch: 14.1.3
Mode: Normal
Competition: World Super League
Progress: 10 league games
Tactics entry:

Super League A
BARCELONA: 4141 by andrichbrand new
CHELSEA: Arrigo Sacchi 4-4-2
BAYERN: Callamity's-Best-Tactic-FM14
MAN CITY: Chrissy pressure

Super League B
JUVENTUS: Fanta 3-1-5-1 Amen FM14
MAN UNITED: R V1 Zero Sea's Rage
PARIS SG: Trophy_whorder
REAL MADRID: ****** 451 v2

Leagues:
View attachment 459703View attachment 459702View attachment 459701View attachment 459700

Selected Matches:
View attachment 459699View attachment 459698View attachment 459697View attachment 459696

Cup:
View attachment 459695View attachment 459694View attachment 459693View attachment 459692

Selected Matches:

View attachment 459691View attachment 459690View attachment 459689View attachment 459688

Notes:

- Callamity leads League A by 5 points.
- ****** leads League B by 4 points.
- Chrissy and ****** is still unbeaten in the league.
- Best offense: ****** and Chrissy
- Best defense: ****** and Fanta
- Cup survivors: Andrich, Callamity, Chrissy, ******, and Fanta.
 
Last edited:
Can I please be the first one to put my tactic up for testing please.
Here it is: View attachment 406943
And here"s my thread: http://www.fm-base.co.uk/forum/share-download-fm-14-tactics/143309-different-451-tactic-success.html

Must appreciated. And keep up the good work!
(H)

Thanks mate, one of your tactic is currently tested in the pre-testing. I plugged it on Barca. Struggling a bit in the league, but it stays strong in the cup. Btw, for some reasons, the MLC got injured quite often. Maybe just coincedent.

Can you try mine as well. I'm now in the third season with Wolves sitting 6th in PremiershipView attachment 407039

Sure, you are up next! Btw are you Xenon from FM 12? THE Xenon??? oO)
 
Thank you for testing my tactic.

As long as I stay top goal scorer I will be happy. Was getting stick that my strikers dont score enough. But it looks like they doing good. (H) And my central defender is one of the top performers.
 
Last edited:
Results Update (Pre-testing)

Patch: 14.1.3
Mode: Normal
Competition: World Super League
Progress: 16 league games
Tactics entry:

Super League A
BARCELONA: 4141 by andrichbrand new
CHELSEA: Arrigo Sacchi 4-4-2
BAYERN: Callamity's-Best-Tactic-FM14
MAN CITY: Chrissy pressure

Super League B
JUVENTUS: Fanta 3-1-5-1 Amen FM14
MAN UNITED: R V1 Zero Sea's Rage
PARIS SG: Trophy_whorder
REAL MADRID: ****** 451 v2

Leagues:
View attachment 459685View attachment 459684View attachment 459683View attachment 459682

Selected Matches:

View attachment 459681View attachment 459680View attachment 459671View attachment 459668

Cup:

View attachment 459679View attachment 459678View attachment 459677View attachment 459676

Selected Matches:

View attachment 459675View attachment 459674View attachment 459673View attachment 459672

Notes:
- Callamity still leading League A by 5 points.
- ****** now leading League B by 9 points!
- Best offence: Chrissy
- Best defence: ******
- Cup survivors: Andrich, Fanta, and Callamity.
 
Last edited:
Hey Andy, good show once again,

Thanks for testing my tactic, it is nice to see it doing well so far.
 
Great work a_ilfandy, i've always liked these threads.

In the SS you post of the league tables could you show the combined view so we can see the home and away stats? Got a feeling some of these tactics would work much better at home and vice versa.
 
RESULTS UPDATE (Pre-testing)

Patch: 14.1.3
Mode: Normal
Competition: World Super League
Progress: Completed league and cup
Tactics entry:

Super League A
BARCELONA: 4141 by andrichbrand new
CHELSEA: Arrigo Sacchi 4-4-2
BAYERN: Callamity's-Best-Tactic-FM14
MAN CITY: Chrissy pressure

Super League B
JUVENTUS: Fanta 3-1-5-1 Amen FM14
MAN UNITED: R V1 Zero Sea's Rage
PARIS SG: Trophy_whorder
REAL MADRID: ****** 451 v2

Leagues:
View attachment 459343View attachment 459342View attachment 459340View attachment 459339

Selected League Matches:
View attachment 459338View attachment 459337View attachment 459335View attachment 459334

Cup:
View attachment 459332View attachment 459331View attachment 459330View attachment 459329

Selected Cup Matches:

View attachment 459328View attachment 459327View attachment 459326View attachment 459325

Notes:
- Callamity won League A by 10 points!
- ****** also won League B by 10 points!
- Callamity only beaten once in 22 league games.
- Best offense: Callamity, Chrissy, and Zero Sea (44 goals)
- Best defense: ****** (12 conceded)
- Cup: Callamity will face Andrich in the Finals!
- Playoffs: Trophy Whorder is the only tactic didnt qualify for the playoffs.
 
Great work a_ilfandy, i've always liked these threads.

In the SS you post of the league tables could you show the combined view so we can see the home and away stats? Got a feeling some of these tactics would work much better at home and vice versa.

Thanks mate. Yeah, thats a good idea. I'll do that starting the next round. Thanks again.. :)

Can you post links to the tactic threads?

Owh yeah. I forgot. Give me few minutes to get it ready. Thanks for the reminder..

Here you go:

PRE-TESTING Tactics Entry:


Super League A
BARCELONA: 4141 by andrichbrand new
http://www.fm-base.co.uk/forum/share-download-fm-14-tactics/143309-different-451-tactic-success.html
CHELSEA: Arrigo Sacchi 4-4-2
http://www.fm-base.co.uk/forum/share-download-fm-14-tactics/142968-arrigo-sacchis-4-4-2-fm14.html
BAYERN: Callamity's-Best-Tactic-FM14
http://www.fm-base.co.uk/forum/share-download-fm-14-tactics/144789-my-best-tactic-fm14.html
MAN CITY: Chrissy pressure
http://www.fm-base.co.uk/forum/shar...essure-tactic-epl-win-everton-1st-season.html

Super League B
JUVENTUS: Fanta 3-1-5-1 Amen FM14
http://www.fm-base.co.uk/forum/shar.../145015-fanta-3-1-5-1-amen-fm14-14-1-3-a.html
MAN UNITED: R V1 Zero Sea's Rage
http://www.fm-base.co.uk/forum/shar...-zero-seas-rage-100-_-real-343-ml-mr-3st.html
PARIS SG: Trophy_whorder
http://www.fm-base.co.uk/forum/shar...43591-trophy_whorder-fm14-counter-tactic.html
REAL MADRID: ****** 451 v2
http://www.fm-base.co.uk/forum/share-download-fm-14-tactics/142834-w4nkers-tactics.html
 
Last edited:
Top