Dybala, definitely.
On my Utd save he was top scorer and assists in first season. And in the second season he got something like 46 goals in 30 odd games and 15 assists. Can't tell you exactly coz I'm away from my PC. This includes being out injured for 5 weeks. The second season isn't over yet...
I think this is because you have your mentality set to Attacking. This is basically instructing your players to get the ball up the pitch as fast as possible therefore bypassing the midfield and reducing the chance of neat inter-play. Try scaling back to control or even standard and see what...
I don't know what he was like before, but I've just completed my first season with Forest and he came back strong from the long lay-off + helped me to win the Championship!! I'm at work so I can't give you any stats - games/goals/assists - but I do remember him making a significant contribution...