On the screenshot you have a Fullback Support and a Sweeper Keeper while on the tactic it's 2 FB attack and a simple keeper, maybe it's why there is a defense problem ?
Does someone know a great 4-1-2-1-2 narrow diamond tactic ? This formation is my favorite but no one has exploited it :/
That would be interesting making a tweak of one of Mr L. tac with this formation, i might try...lol