Low rating cause most of that saves are easy. This tactics created many half chance, therefore the opposition GK is always busy with easy shots. The 'Much higher tempo' is also credited for that. But only great saves can boost his rating.
@dimartino, because you are so keen on your tactic, please give us a test in normal FM, not FMC. The AI in FMC can't handle 3 ST formations FYI, so your result is really pointless.
There are a lot of real life tactics in this forum, and of course you will have the real life results for it, and it'll soon become unpopular. Some tactics exploit the match engine a bit and become "not real", but the results are much better and the tactics will be always at the first page...
I followed two quick tips:
1. Boost the team bonus money in all cup, league
2. Never use teamtalk in the first quarter of season
Won everything with Chelsea first season :)
The less team and player instruction you put, the more variation a tactic can get through in match shouts. I'm unsure about whether those ones are suitable for the word 'consistent'.