I have just completed my first season on Football Manager 2024 and whilst using this tactic with Arsenal, we won every single competition we competed in, securing a famous quintuple! Also in the Premier League we scored a whopping 109 goals, whilst only conceding 28 and securing Arsenal's record points tally of 94.
I used the same instructions and player roles for 95% of the matches, I tweaked things slightly away to bigger teams in the early stages of the season, changing the IWB(ATT) to IWB(SUP) and the LCB (Usually Gabriel) from BPD(DEF) to CD(DEF). Also against much weaker opposition, such as Burnley and Luton, I changed the mentality from Positive to Attacking.
I used the same instructions and player roles for 95% of the matches, I tweaked things slightly away to bigger teams in the early stages of the season, changing the IWB(ATT) to IWB(SUP) and the LCB (Usually Gabriel) from BPD(DEF) to CD(DEF). Also against much weaker opposition, such as Burnley and Luton, I changed the mentality from Positive to Attacking.