If the players an the team have the exact same settings apart from the counterbox ticked or unticked, Using counter attacks means that once in possession after breaking up attacks, the players will launch attacks even though that the opponent sits with many men behind the ball. When not having the box ticked, the players will take lesser risks and instead hold om to the ball if outnumbered up front
With this said, its à bigger risk using counter if the opponent sits with many men behind the ball as you might loose it whilst your whole team is getting forward, just as its à bigger risk not pushimg forward using counter attacks if the opponent are pushing up , putting pressure on you