Appealing against a Red Card

K

Kieranchelsea

Member
Joined
May 8, 2009
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Have you ever manager to get a Red Card overturned?

I have never been able to successfully appeal against a red card
 
I never appeal unless my trusty *** man says it's worth doing, got a few match bans in my first season when my team decided it would go on a killing spread mid season and I had to appeal to keep players.
 
No! I dont even bother anymore because it never gets overturned. If I'm asked in the press conference i just say no comment.
 
Never. Personally I think it's a bug, and whenever I do appeal; they decide to slap on an extra two-matches.
 
I just go and fine my players wages unless hes balotelli then i jump ignore the whole situation
 
Munroe said:
Never. Personally I think it's a bug, and whenever I do appeal; they decide to slap on an extra two-matches.
Click to expand...

I think it's realistic. In real life red cards are only overturned in the case of really extreme injustices, like mistaken identity, to protect the principle that The Referee Is Always Right. If the ref maintains that he e.g. saw your player elbow another, the FA simply doesn't have the power to overrule him, even if everyone can see on the video he was wrong. Correct me if I'm wrong.

I appealed a red card once when my centre-back got a straight red for deliberately handling the ball in an aerial duel about ten yards from the penalty area. Still can't figure out why that was a red, there wasn't any chance of a goal. It stood, but no extra ban.
 
i have never given fines OR appealed against a red card. i can mutter something about "ruining the game for us" in press conference, but i usually issue a warning to the player, who accepts it, and we keep whatever suspension the swedish FA handles us. notably, in FM11 i never had a player complaining against a warning after a red card
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

FMBase

Beta

Resources

Back
Top