Everton 1st season...
Coleman 3.5/5 star is now some how 2,5 after playing every game.
Distan 3/3.5 star now 2 star
Barry is 2.5star HOW???
Howard is 2.5 star
Neil Taylor is 2 star
Star ratings are all relative, players are compared against your squad. Coleman would be 5 star in a league 1 team but probably 2/3 star at Real Madrid.
The star ratings are not relevant if you have a good coach/scout go by what they say he could be 2 and a half star but still described as a leading premiership right back