Gaya and Grimaldo

[mikcheck]

Hello,

If you had to pick between Gaya and Grimaldo, which one you'd go for? Gaya's attributes are slighly better than Grimaldo, but Grimaldo average ratings are really impressive.

 

[Mredd2010]

I play as Spurs, 3rd Season now and narrowed it down to the same choice after Ben Davies was sold. I went with Gaya fee rising up to £26M purely because i had Grimaldo on last years FM and had not signed Gaya before. They are both very similar and both a good option. After I had agreed the transfer for Gaya, Grimaldo got unhappy and Man City signed him for just £13m..so may be worth tapping them both up.

 

[mikcheck]

So you already played them both. They're equally good? Doesnt Grimaldo get better ratings?

In my save Grimaldo has 7,56 and Gaya 7,10

Thanks.

 

[NoviceTrevor]

I think a lot of it depends on what side you're putting them in to. I've currently got Gaya in a Real Madrid side and he plays really well and chips in with goals and assists but that's Real Madrid where the LB is basically playing as a second winger.

Taking a look at them both here, Grimaldo is on fire for Arsenal while Gaya seems to have struggled at Chelsea but he's performed really well at a struggling/relegated Everton side. (Pics below)

View attachment 95566

View attachment 95565

 

[mikcheck]

Thank you.

What is impressive to me is that Grimaldo always has similar outstanding average rating in EVERY save i do, and apparentely in other people's saves too. And i think that's why i'll go for Grimaldo, even though he will be more expensive than Gaya.