Help with Striker Choice

[Robeni]

Hi, I'm looking for a other people's opinions on this. I'm struggling to choose between keeping a striker or selling him and buying a certain new striker to replace him at Man Utd. I've thought about it for ages but I can't seem to make my mind up and I'd appreciate if anyone could give their opinion.

Here are what I believe are the key benefits/drawbacks for each striker.

Striker 1('Andrea de Carlo' already at the club
Reasons to keep:

1. Better Stats
2. Slightly lower wage
3. Manageable personality
4. Fits in team
5. Happy to be on bench
6. Trained in Nation HG status

Reasons to sell:

1. Getting older (30 yrs value + ability will decline)
2. Form last season worse than last few
3. Can sell for decent £32 million

Striker 2('Fernando' at Real Madrid)
Reasons to buy:

1. Good if not quite as good stats (imo)
2. £14million release clause at Real
3. Younger by 5 years
4. Average rating of 8.00 in La Liga last season

Reasons not to buy:

1. Higher wage demands
2. Less likeable personality (I have problems with quite a few Brazilians as well for some reason
3. Already have loads of Brazilians in the team, I know it's not a problem but I like having a mix. Atm I'm worried it's just becoming Brazilians, Argentinians and English

Here's the striker I have


And here's the other


Thanks For your help^^)

 

[arsenal3642]

If i where you i would try and sell andrea de carlo for as much as possible and replace him with fernando . fernando does look better because of age and he has everything to be a good replacement.

 

[Lol_101]

Fernando is Andrea's replacement. sell andrea for like 17m and use the money combined with the budget to buy Fernando for 14m+
* 14m release clause is quite low for a player with such quality.

if his release clause is 14m, then i would just get him, have have both, since Adrea could be a great tutor.

 

[Robeni]

OK thanks, done and dusted. Maybe I was just a bit unwilling to let my star go :'(
View attachment 189688View attachment 189689