If you want real value for the matchday experience Dunc then obviously Newcastle is the clear winner, cheaper nightclubs/drink prices than anywhere else and obviously going to watch Cabaye/Tiote midfield combo is well worth the 17.50 to get in.
I would vote for NUFC as the best matchday experience, as a kid it was always THE game we looked forward to the Tyne-Tees derby. Our ticket prices used to be 24 for an adult and 12 for U-16s, I think they've gone down since we got relegated but I wouldn't know don't go to many matches because it's not really possible and we're *it.
I always assumed NUFC/AVFC from our time in the PL.
I know this is old news but QPR are charging 35 a ticket?
Just get in the car and go watch Chelsea, that's a ridiculous price.