Mentality - standart and some times in control against the smaller teams.
FLuidity - I rarely touched it
In my situation the tactic doesnt mather really because its nothing unusual and cant explain the stats. Here are my problems:
1. The opposite teams almost always have a decent chance in the first two minutes. I received goal in the 2nd minute in the last 3 of 10 matches
2. I receive an average one goal from corner per match in the last three seasons!!! Crossing at the near post and the ***** from my edn start. Cant find from were I can give instructions about the corners, I remember that at the old versions you could have but still wingbacks should be at the post and everytime Baines or Colman just do nothing there, no fight, no defense
3. The opposite team always have at least 20 shots against my goal even playing at home against huge underdogs.
4. I lost a two goal lead at least 5 times not to mention how manny times the other team recovered one goal and went to miss manny more chances, this last scenario happen at least 10 times.
All the upper mentioned things are so unrealistic that in my eyes they cant be explained without a huge game bug. So I am searching for a fix here not a different tactic. If it happens to be that the problem is in me and my tactic than please tell me so I can delete the game for good.
By the sounds of it, your corner tactics are nothing short of appalling, and your main tactic is not much better.
1. If, as you claim, teams are running through you and scoring after 2 minutes, then you need to go more defensive.How is this not obvious! Perhaps you should also look into retaining possession, and starting games more cautiously.
2: Sort your corner tactics out. If you can't find where the instructions are, asking politely would better serve you than ranting at someone.
3. Be more defensive. Even a sh*t team can beat a big team if they don't defend properly. Just look at this weekend's FA Cup results for example. City and Chelsea were poor defensively; got punished.
4. All out attacking for 90 minutes won't help you. As WJ mentions, the AI doesn't roll over. Perhaps you need to consider being more cautious once you have reached a possibly secure position, rather than continuing to attack and being punished.
Rather than crying "bug", and suggesting that you are infallable, how about you listen to some of the people best placed to help you. If it was a "bug", as you suggest, then I would expect that I would have the same problem, and that many others would also.
Edit: And before you mention again that it is Everton, and that they have a good defence, that means b*gger all. Just look at how they are doing IRL.
Edit (Again): Of course, without a proper screenshot of your tactics, and your instructions, it is very difficult for anybody to actually help, if that is what you are looking for.