It varies - I've seen 5 silvers both above and below .5 gold. It happens because older players can't drop into silver stars, so the 0.5 gold players can range anywhere from utterly useless to backup's backup quality. In concrete terms: If you're in the Prem and, for whatever reason, signed one player who would be average in L2 and one who would be average in BSS, both would be .5, but you could (and would) have 4.5 and 5 silver star players ranked above the BSS guy on the depth chart while still possibly being below the L2 player.i think 5 silver stars is roughly 1 gold star, maybe 1 and a half as i've seen silver star players above half gold star players on my coach report before.