Transitioning to club football management from an NFL-style

  • Thread starter Thread starter wmute
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 2
  • Views Views 958

wmute

Member
Joined
Sep 11, 2010
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
Points
0
I've been playing Football Manager for half a year now and although I have the first-team phase of the game down, I'm having a difficult time in terms of developping and bringing in young players whom I hope to eventually feature on my first team squad.

A bit of background: I've been more of an NFL fan for most of my life, and naturally, Madden has been a big part of my gaming life. For so long, I've played Madden in a "manager" style, without touching gameplay and merely running the team, signing players and bringing in young raw talents that eventually take the place of departing free agents.

Often, great players straight out of college, I plug them straight into my offense. It's more common in american football, but not so much in soccer, where most players generally peak at a later age.

My difficulties are centered around what to do with great, under 20 players in terms of eventually having them play on the first team. When investing in young 16-17 year old players, is there a proper strategy in determining whether I should keep their development in-house or loan them out for first-team experience. Along with that, once in their young 20s is it best to send them right to the end of my first teaem bench, or continue to send them out on loan?

I'm also not accustomed to the use of the Reserves team. While playing FM2010, I totally disregarded my reserves and only had players on my First Team and Under 20s. It definitely felt like there was a step missing regarding development cause my players would complain often about not wanting to be loaned out.

Seems like Baseball and Hockey are closest to the management style of these players, what with baseball having the different AAA, AA, etc levels, and hockey having the Junior/minors/nhl leagues.

Any input for those of us that're having trouble with this? More specifically, what should my roster/depth chart look like? Aside from the first eleven, how many more players should I have on the squad, how many should be on the reserves? How often should I be buying young players for my under 20s, how many "hot prospects" should I have on it?
 
Last edited:
I usually keep my youngsters in house until they turn 18-20, then I start to loan them out, if a club where they realistically can compete for a first team spot offers to loan them.
Until that I keep them on custom training schedules and use older player to mentor them. I keep them in my junior team, and make them available for reserve matches so they play as many matches as possible, and they also get half a match or so in very easy matches.

This way has worked well for me.
 
You should try to offer your young players the best possible training and match experience. Sadly this may mean sending them out on loan because the reserve League is just not good enough to develop them. When sending them out on loan, always use the club that will play them and has Good training facilities. This means they're more likely to develop as a player. Alternatively, you can throw them in the deep end straight away but if you're a top team in the top League, this is never going to work unless they're exceptional already. Always include the recall from loan feature when sending a player out on loan so you can get them back if you think they're not developing correctly or fast enough.

If you want to look into training schedules, some of our members have uploaded them to the site here.
 
Back
Top