Who is best defensive Midfielder on FM 2012 "M'vila or Fellaini"?

[swappysnipes]

I have used both on fm 12 n cant really differentiate between the two. Because both were good players. But i just wanna knw who is the best. n they not the best there is, anyone know of other defensive midfielders better than these players on fm 2012?

 

[Snypar]

Fellaini is better than M'Vila, but there's no noticeable difference between the two. As for who's better, Mascherano and Sandro are better than Fellaini, Alex Song and Busquetes are better than M'Vila.

Sandro
Mascherano
Fellaini
Song
Busquetes
M'vila

All in all, there's very little between all of them.

 

[prempz]

intresting thread i was going to sell lucas on my liverpool team to get m'villa

 

[slbenficacoach]

Ballotelli!

 

[Audiotwist]

Im gonna say Song. Ayew has amazing physical attributes but his PA is only around high 160's I think, and he's more of a box to box/playmaker.
Everytime I play song as a DPL/BWM I win against whoever i'm playing, he's beast.

 

[nedu99]

M'Vila is the best DM on Fm12 to me....only disadvantage is his height ..he can get up to 15 asissts a season if u use him him full potential...he wins d ball superbly! sometimes he covers for players who r out of position!

 

[Adz_14]

If you were looking at a mid-table side in the prem or even a top side maybe, then in my experience Mohamed Diame is an absolute beast.

 

[JUSSI75]

What about Fernando?

 

[mccollio09]

M'Vila between the two, but Sandro is definitely better than both.

 

[Raikan007]

None of the above!

Fernando is quality, he became World class in my Tottenham save!

These are all three years in, Vukojevic is better at the start!

View attachment 237060View attachment 237062View attachment 237063View attachment 237064View attachment 237066View attachment 237067View attachment 237068

 

[imperador234]

Both of them are expensive... Personally, I prefer Sandro Ranieri, from tottenham, Fernando Reges from FCPorto or Nainggolan
Kara is good too, and he is interested in signing for all the clubs, because he is playing for a low team

 

[duca]

Kara is outstanding, he can reach to 20 of tackle easily and he is very cheap and tall, with the right training he turns a beast

 

[pompey forever99]

how about de rossi, de jong, xabi alonso there amazing and lassana diarra awesome player.also yaya toure and eventhough he is old marcos senna but i do agree with yann m'vila

 

[pompey forever99]

AND I FORGOT MY FAVOURITE FRIMPONG YOU JUST GOT FRIMPONGED DENCH !

 

[nedu99]

still think M'Vila is the best i don't see any other DM giving me 10-15 assists per season...Vidal is the only one who comes close ..i think it also depends on the style of play of your team

 

[mnk26]

How has nobody mentioned Javier Mascherano? Easily the best DM in the game, won't help out offensively like m'villa but 18 marking 20 tackling, come on! And his mental stats are insane.