No, they aren't out of date. I use them. The Excel they link to works right for exact calculation. The site I made using it works right if you prefer the web https://fm-15-coach.herokuapp.com/ .
Thanks for replying bennymc.
Really, good job on the database.
I've experimented personally on these things and I know how long just a fraction of the work you've done takes so once again, great job and thanks
Bennymc, please can you reupload your fm2011 dbc file?
The link on neoseeker for your fm2011 dbc has been deleted.
Only just the dbc file should be fine imo
I have a feeling it would still work for those with a version of fm12 prior to fm 12.2.2
Thanks