I've tried a few things to achieve that but never got it to work. Until I tried it the other way round: I'm now fielding three DCs (no DM), set the middle DC as Ball player and stopper, increase his mentality and closing down. Like this he steps out the line to press the opponent much earlier as the other two DCs when not in possession but plays more or less on the line with them when in possession, thus behaving more or less like you'd expect from a modern centre half.
However I have to re-test this approach on 11.2 now