Resource icon
- Thread starter drlw1980
- Start date
- Replies 22
- Views 10K
purefection_123
Member
- Joined
- Aug 8, 2009
- Messages
- 6
- Reaction score
- 2
- Points
- 3
Solid so far!
Which team? Results?
I haven’t experimented with the roles, but i think you should try and let me hear if it works!
magicnut
Member
- Joined
- Aug 4, 2015
- Messages
- 290
- Reaction score
- 101
- Points
- 43
Lad I'm sorry to cut to the chase with you a tad but when you say your team is "established in the top of the premier league" one would assume the team IS actually on the top of the premier league and also at the end of the season and not after 8 games 
I mean your results are maybe not the worst one ever saw but nothing extraordinary with it after all effectively you won 0 trophees *EDIT: ok 1 league cup in 8 seasons and thats it" with the tactic in 8 seasons. Of course I am not trying to be on the offensive or anything and one is free to post whatever tactic here they wish but lads here in general tend to be interested in the fine and dandy working tactics and I don't see so far that you have much to show for it.
I mean your results are maybe not the worst one ever saw but nothing extraordinary with it after all effectively you won 0 trophees *EDIT: ok 1 league cup in 8 seasons and thats it
" with the tactic in 8 seasons. Of course I am not trying to be on the offensive or anything and one is free to post whatever tactic here they wish but lads here in general tend to be interested in the fine and dandy working tactics and I don't see so far that you have much to show for it.Did you try it?Lad I'm sorry to cut to the chase with you a tad but when you say your team is "established in the top of the premier league" one would assume the team IS actually on the top of the premier league and also at the end of the season and not after 8 games
I mean your results are maybe not the worst one ever saw but nothing extraordinary with it after all effectively you won 0 trophees *EDIT: ok 1 league cup in 8 seasons and thats it
magicnut
Member
- Joined
- Aug 4, 2015
- Messages
- 290
- Reaction score
- 101
- Points
- 43
Nope and the reason why is or rather the reasons:Did you try it?
1). The results you've showed on this tactic are nothing extraordinary and I have an abundance of tactics that I'm confident for fact would bring better results than that. I won the bundesliga my first season with hertha berlin using mostly my own tactic DopeCookies (vast majority of games) but I have some tactics in reserve I have way more confidence in than this
.2). The nature of this tactic namely a 4-3-3 V formation , attacking mentality , higher defensive line and all that kind of stuff is an oldschool approach that I know for fact doesn't work on this engine too well .
Ok.Nope and the reason why is or rather the reasons:
1). The results you've showed on this tactic are nothing extraordinary and I have an abundance of tactics that I'm confident for fact would bring better results than that. I won the bundesliga my first season with hertha berlin using mostly my own tactic DopeCookies (vast majority of games) but I have some tactics in reserve I have way more confidence in than this
2). The nature of this tactic namely a 4-3-3 V formation , attacking mentality , higher defensive line and all that kind of stuff is an oldschool approach that I know for fact doesn't work on this engine too well .
I've started a new game with Rochdale in League 2, pred 24th, just to test with another team. Signed 3 youth players on loan. 10 league matches:Nope and the reason why is or rather the reasons:
1). The results you've showed on this tactic are nothing extraordinary and I have an abundance of tactics that I'm confident for fact would bring better results than that. I won the bundesliga my first season with hertha berlin using mostly my own tactic DopeCookies (vast majority of games) but I have some tactics in reserve I have way more confidence in than this
2). The nature of this tactic namely a 4-3-3 V formation , attacking mentality , higher defensive line and all that kind of stuff is an oldschool approach that I know for fact doesn't work on this engine too well .
I think this is pretty ok results for a bad tactic...
magicnut
Member
- Joined
- Aug 4, 2015
- Messages
- 290
- Reaction score
- 101
- Points
- 43
@
drlw1980
Lad thats a decent start to a season but all that stuff is irrelevant to me personally because for me:
1). A solid indication can only be made based on how a tactic performs at the highest divisions. On a level as low as league 2 no offense but often time even very crappy rubbish tactics (and I'm not necessarily saying yours is but nevertheless) often times perform above any kind of expectations .People often have a misconseption that somehow its "harder" to make a tactic work at lower levels of play but i'll tell you its just the contrary , in fact I have seen MANY rubbish tactics do seemingly good jobs until tested at the higher level.
2) As said before effectively you won 0 throphees with your tactic on that sheffied wednesday save in 8 seasons. To me thats the biggest giveaway. Lad any worthwhile tactic IMHO the author demonstrates that they won something with it. You won: 1 league cup in 8 seasons and thats it.
3). Any kind of indication of a achievement of a tactic should only be shown at the end of a season because results after like 9 games are really irrelevant . For instance I still easily believe you can finish like mid table ish on that new save you started with the Rochdale come the end of the season.
drlw1980
Lad thats a decent start to a season but all that stuff is irrelevant to me personally because for me:
1). A solid indication can only be made based on how a tactic performs at the highest divisions. On a level as low as league 2 no offense but often time even very crappy rubbish tactics (and I'm not necessarily saying yours is but nevertheless
) often times perform above any kind of expectations .People often have a misconseption that somehow its "harder" to make a tactic work at lower levels of play but i'll tell you its just the contrary , in fact I have seen MANY rubbish tactics do seemingly good jobs until tested at the higher level.2) As said before effectively you won 0 throphees with your tactic on that sheffied wednesday save in 8 seasons. To me thats the biggest giveaway. Lad any worthwhile tactic IMHO the author demonstrates that they won something with it. You won: 1 league cup in 8 seasons and thats it.
3). Any kind of indication of a achievement of a tactic should only be shown at the end of a season because results after like 9 games are really irrelevant . For instance I still easily believe you can finish like mid table ish on that new save you started with the Rochdale come the end of the season
.I accept your skepticism, but I think it would be more classy to test it before judging it. I'll post end of season results with Rochdale.@
drlw1980
Lad thats a decent start to a season but all that stuff is irrelevant to me personally because for me:
1). A solid indication can only be made based on how a tactic performs at the highest divisions. On a level as low as league 2 no offense but often time even very crappy rubbish tactics (and I'm not necessarily saying yours is but nevertheless
2) As said before effectively you won 0 throphees with your tactic on that sheffied wednesday save in 8 seasons. To me thats the biggest giveaway. Lad any worthwhile tactic IMHO the author demonstrates that they won something with it. You won: 1 league cup in 8 seasons and thats it.
3). Any kind of indication of a achievement of a tactic should only be shown at the end of a season because results after like 9 games are really irrelevant . For instance I still easily believe you can finish like mid table ish on that new save you started with the Rochdale come the end of the season
Nope and the reason why is or rather the reasons:
1). The results you've showed on this tactic are nothing extraordinary and I have an abundance of tactics that I'm confident for fact would bring better results than that. I won the bundesliga my first season with hertha berlin using mostly my own tactic DopeCookies (vast majority of games) but I have some tactics in reserve I have way more confidence in than this
2). The nature of this tactic namely a 4-3-3 V formation , attacking mentality , higher defensive line and all that kind of stuff is an oldschool approach that I know for fact doesn't work on this engine too well .
Where is your DopeCookies tactic? Fancy giving that a run out .
magicnut
Member
- Joined
- Aug 4, 2015
- Messages
- 290
- Reaction score
- 101
- Points
- 43
I published it on the steam workshop lad cba to do a fmbase post but here it is https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=2987676549
Cheers bud