AI Manager challenge

stothy862

Member
Joined
Dec 27, 2009
Messages
142
Reaction score
0
Points
16
A friend of mine is hosting this. PM me your info and I will forward it on to him.

Post 1: Details of the game
Post 2: FAQ and Example


THE MANAGER FM GAME

This is a little experiment to see who is the best manager on FM, when they become an AI manager!

You can sign up to this experiment by PM'ing me with the following information in italics (you can fill in the optional bits too of course).

Some quick notes first:

- Your manager reputation is set between 1 and 10,000. It will be set at exactly 500 above the reputation of the club or nation you manage.
- Everything is out of 20 unless I've said otherwise.
- You may only choose clubs from the following leagues:

England: - Premier League or Championship
Spain: - La Liga or Liga Adelante
Italy - Serie A or B
Germany - Bundesliga
France - Ligue Une
Netherlands - Eredivisie
Portugal - Liga Sagres
Scotland - SPL or First Division
Argentina - Primera Division only
Brazil - Brasileirao Serie A only.

International - Any country that competes in Competitive matches.

Essential:

Name:
Date of Birth: (Ideally so you're between 33 and 45 years old):
Nationalities:
International Record:

1st Choice Club/Nation to manage:
2nd Choice Club/Nation to manage:
3rd Choice Club/Nation to manage:
4th Choice Club/Nation to manage:
5th Choice Club/Nation to manage:
6th Choice Club/Nation to manage:
7th Choice Club/Nation to manage:

Languages Spoken:

Skill Level (1-200):

Preferred Formation:
Second Preferred Formation:




Optional:

Place of Birth:

Adaptability:
Ambition:
Controversy:
Loyalty:
Pressure Handling:
Professionalism:
Sportsmanship:
Temperament:

Defensive Formation:
Attacking Formation:

Attacking Tendency:
Tendency to use depth:
Determination:
Directness:
Dirtiness:
Flamboyance:
Flexibility:
Free Roles allowance:
Man Marking tendency:
Likelihood to play offside trap:
Level of pressing (20 is very high up the pitch):
Likelihood to sit back:
Tactical Knowledge:
Speed of Tempo:
Likelihood to use a playmaker:
Likelihood to use substitutes:
Tendency to use Width:

Hardness of training:
Judging Player Ability:
Judging Player Potential:
Level Of Discipline:
Man Management:
Likelihood to play mind games:
Motivating:
Lieklihood to use Squad Rotation:
Working with Youngsters:
Attacking Coaching:
Defensive Coaching:
Fitness Coaching:
Goalie Coaching:
Mental Coaching:
Tactical Coaching:
Technical Coaching:

Tends to sign Domestic Players:
Spends a lot on youth players:
Signs a lot of Youth Players:
Signs Youth Players for the First Team:
Uses all of their budget on one player:
Has a large senior squad:
Will use young players in low priority matches:
Will make early tactical changes:
Will use zonal marking at set pieces:
Will fit players into preferred tactic:
Will use a target man:
Will use counter attacking:


Favoured People (5 max):
Disliked People (5 max):
Favoured Clubs (5 max):
Disliked Clubs (5 max):


---------- Post added at 04:50 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:49 PM ----------

FAQ:

1. General Game and Scoring FAQ:

At least 5 created managers must be signed into a division, or else they will be changed to another one.

- Once all the editing is done, I will make the original XML file available.
- I'll run this across different forums, and I'll produce a collective sign up list once everyone is done via Google Docs (you don't need a Google account to view).
- Once the XML file is created. I will create 5 unique games with it (all user-set variables will remain constant - same leagues etc.)
- Each game will run for 20 seasons. Each manager will be attributed a score from each game. The winner will be the manager with highest average score.

2. Skills FAQ

- If you put everything at 20, then the game will punish you. Try to be varied and specific if you are filling it in. A lot of the time, being different makes you a better manager!

3. Club/nation Assignment FAQ

- Clubs will be sorted on a first come, first served and choice priority. No 2nd choice will be given over a later applicants first choice.
- Managers can manage both a club and country if they wish. In this case, if a club is their first choice, they will not be assigned a nation until everyone else has a managerial position. Then it will be done on the same basis as above. For example, if 3 applicants put Spain as their second choice and a club as first choice (the yall got their first choice club and no-one has been given Spain as their main job), then the first applicant will be Spain national team boss, the 2nd will be Spain U21 boss, and the third will be Spain U19 boss.
- In the highly unlikely situation you don't get any of your picks, I will give you a chocie of available posts.
- If all of the clubs are taken in a nation, I will open up the next lower division for applicants also and inform all threads, but once a club has been given, there's no "going back"

4. Scoring System:

- The Scoring system will be released later, after initial testing of the game to balance the scoring.

My example:


Essential:

Name: Mark Webster
Date of Birth: (Ideally so you're between 30 and 45 years old): 13.07.1976 (32 at game start, which is about 01.07.09)
Nationalities: Scottish
International Record: Uncapped

1st Choice Club/Nation to manage: Dundee
2nd Choice Club/Nation to manage: Leverkusen
3rd Choice Club/Nation to manage: Any available SPL team
4th Choice Club/Nation to manage: Any available Scottish First Division Team
5th Choice Club/Nation to manage: Any other available team
6th Choice Club/Nation to manage:
7th Choice Club/Nation to manage:

Languages Spoken: English

Skill Level (1-200): 170

Preferred Formation: 4-1-2-2-1
Second Preferred Formation: 4-4-2




Optional:

Place of Birth: Dundee

Adaptability: 16
Ambition: 14
Controversy: 11
Loyalty: 12
Pressure Handling: 11
Professionalism: 12
Sportsmanship: 10
Temperament: 19

Defensive Formation: 4-1-4-1
Attacking Formation: 4-3-3

Attacking Tendency: 16
Tendency to use depth: 10
Determination: 16
Directness: 8
Dirtiness: 2
Tactical Flamboyance: 12
Tactical Flexibility: 18
Free Roles allowance: 4
Man Marking tendency: 7
Likelihood to play offside trap: 1
Level of pressing (20 is very high up the pitch): 16
Likelihood to sit back: 7
Tactical Knowledge: 17
Speed of Tempo: 14
Likelihood to use a playmaker: 14
Likelihood to use substitutes: 19
Tendency to use Width: 14

Hardness of training: 12
Judging Player Ability: 16
Judging Player Potential: 19
Level Of Discipline: 11
Man Management: 16
Likelihood to play mind games: 9
Motivating: 14
Lieklihood to use Squad Rotation: 6
Working with Youngsters: 18
Attacking Coaching: Not bothered
Defensive Coaching: Not bothered
Fitness Coaching: Not bothered
Goalie Coaching: Not bothered
Mental Coaching: Not bothered
Tactical Coaching: Not bothered
Technical Coaching: Not bothered

Tends to sign Domestic Players: No tendency
Spends a lot on youth players: 15
Signs a lot of Youth Players: 16
Signs Youth Players for the First Team: No tendency
Uses all of their budget on one player: 11
Has a large senior squad: No tendency
Will use young players in low priority matches: 14
Will make early tactical changes: No tendency
Will use zonal marking at set pieces: No tendency
Will fit players into preferred tactic: 8
Will use a target man: 8
Will use counter attacking: 15


Favoured People (5 max): Leigh Griffiths, Gary Harkins, Kris Boyd
Disliked People (5 max): None
Favoured Clubs (5 max): Dundee
Disliked Clubs (5 max): Dundee United
 
great idea im inovlved
 
Please pm all information.

---------- Post added at 08:43 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:01 PM ----------

1 WEEK deadline.

---------- Post added at 04:41 PM ---------- Previous post was yesterday at 08:43 PM ----------

If you're short of time then just fill this in and PM it to me, this is all you will ever need to do for this game!

Name:
Date of Birth: (Ideally so you're between 33 and 45 years old):
Nationalities:


1st Choice Club/Nation to manage:
2nd Choice Club/Nation to manage:
3rd Choice Club/Nation to manage:
4th Choice Club/Nation to manage:
5th Choice Club/Nation to manage:
6th Choice Club/Nation to manage:
7th Choice Club/Nation to manage:

Languages Spoken:

Skill Level (1-200):

Preferred Formation:
Second Preferred Formation:

Any particular style of play you would tell your team to play? (Short passing, long passing, attacking/defensive, wide/narrow, man/zonal marking, counter attack, target man/playmaker, fast/slow tempo etc. etc.)

Any particular manager tendencies you have? (Sign a lot of youth players, spend your entire budget on one player, sign domestic based players etc.)


---------- Post added at 05:06 PM ---------- Previous post was yesterday at 04:41 PM ----------

Here are the first choices so far (all these teams are taken)

Dundee
Valencia
Ayr
FC Bayern
Barcelona
Man City
Doncaster Rovers
Man Utd
Man Utd
Arsenal
Forest
Finland
Spurs
Ipswich
Chelsea
Barcelona
Sheff Utd
Man Utd
Chelsea
Inter
Celtic
Udinese
AZ
Arsenal
Spurs
Arsenal
Man Utd
Celtic
Norwich
Man Utd
Bolton
Arsenal
Arsenal
Man Utd
Fiorentina
Bochum
Liverpool
Man City
At. Madrid
Inverness CT
Liverpool
Man City

At 50 players now! Keep it coming, I want to get 100!
 
Code:
Ricky		Gill		SI	AC Milan		(none)
Ben		Mayhook		GPRO	Arsenal			(none)
Alex		Hawkins		GPRO	Aston Villa		(none)
Renaldi		Narendra	GPRO	At. Madrid		(none)
Kostas		Farsalinos	GPRO	Athletic		Greece
Iain		Bartholomew	GPRO	Ayr			(none)
Koen		De Heldt	GPRO	AZ			(none)
Carlos		Villacastin	GPRO	Barcelona		Spain U21
Lukas		Giniotis	GPRO	Birmingham City		France
Keith		Addo-Dadzie	FMBase	Blackburn		Ghana
Paul		Gardiner	GPRO	Boca			Australia U21
Jonathan	Beagles		GPRO	Bochum			Croatia
Jouni		Tolvanen	GPRO	Bolton			Finland U21
Ioannis		Dimitroglou	GPRO	Bordeaux		Spain
Tass		Thorlu-Bangura	FMBase	Cardiff			(none)
Ermin		Covic		GPRO	Celtic			(none)
William		Hall		SI	Chelsea			Australia
Chris		Williams	GPRO	Derby			(none)
Jake		Stothard	GPRO	Doncaster Rovers	Ghana U21
Mark		Webster		GPRO	Dundee			Scotland U21
Kashvinder	Mann		GPRO	Everton			(none)
Maarten		Velhurst	GPRO	FC Twente		(none)
Andreas		Weilemann	GPRO	FC Bayern		(none)
Dan		Dumitras	GPRO	Fiorentina		(none)
Adam		Kerr		SI	Forest			(none)
Lee		Ifans		GPRO	Fulham			Argentina
Daniel		Lewis		OTF2	Genoa			Chile
Chinmay		Dhopate		GPRO	Inter			Italy
Andrei		Ciuchi		GPRO	Inverness CT		England U19
Aleksandr	Bismarck	GPRO	Ipswich			(none)
Binyamin	Radomsky	GPRO	Juventus		(none)
Samuel		Tarry		OTF2	Leicester		(none)
James		Mathews		GPRO	Liverpool		(none)
Joe		Hudson		OTF2	Lyon			(none)
Martin		Carson		GPRO	Man City		(none)
Sam		Bouchard	OTF2	Man Utd			(none)
Janne		Väänänen	GPRO	Monaco			Finland
Sid		Venk		SI	Napoli			(none)
Gordon		Ashford		GPRO	Newcastle		(none)
Saxon		Durrant		GPRO	Norwich			Jamaica
Occam		Razero		SI	Portsmouth		Canada
Dan		Reed		GPRO	PSG			(none)
Halo		Von Stromberg	SI	Rangers			(none)
Kvothe				SI	Reading			USA
Sion		Francis		GPRO	Real Madrid		Wales
Antonio		Pereira		GPRO	River			Senegal
Theo		Panag		GPRO	Roma			(none)
Steve		Axworth		SI	Santos			(none)
Arshad		Jilani		GPRO	Sevilla			France U21
Damian		Weymouth	SI	Sheff Utd		Togo
Toygun		Senler		GPRO	Spurs			(none)
Ben		Cee		SI	Sunderland		England U21
Andy		Taylor		GPRO	Udinese			China
Leonardo	Bittencourt	GPRO	Valencia		(none)
Stewart		Robertson	SI	Wigan			Scotland
Elliot		Hartfree-Pearce	SI	Wolfsburg		England

---------- Post added at 12:27 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:25 AM ----------

"SIGNUP CLOSED!

I'll give everybody who's signed up 24 hours to make any final changes. The 59 entrants are listed below with their scoring handicaps as given by FM itself! (Higher number is a bigger handicap):


Code:
Name Surname Forum Club Nation Club/Nation Rep
Carlos Villacastin GPRO Barcelona Spain U21 9550
Steve Axworth SI Santos Brazil 9550
Sion Francis GPRO Real Madrid Wales 9500
Sam Bouchard OTF2 Man Utd (none) 9350
Chinmay Dhopate GPRO Inter Italy 9250
William Hall SI Chelsea Australia 9100
Lee Ifans GPRO Fulham Argentina 9000
James Mathews GPRO Liverpool (none) 8950
Binyamin Radomsky GPRO Juventus (none) 8850
Andreas Weilemann GPRO FC Bayern (none) 8800
Ricky Gill SI AC Milan (none) 8750
Lukas Giniotis GPRO Birmingham City France 8750
Ben Mayhook GPRO Arsenal (none) 8600
Arshad Jilani GPRO Sevilla France U21 8600
Leonardo Bittencourt GPRO Valencia (none) 8450
Joe Hudson OTF2 Lyon (none) 8400
Renaldi Narendra GPRO At. Madrid (none) 8350
Martin Tajcnár GPRO Porto Portugal 8300
Ioannis Dimitroglou GPRO Bordeaux Spain 8250
Dan Dumitras GPRO Fiorentina (none) 8150
Theo Panag GPRO Roma (none) 8150
Paul Gardiner GPRO Boca Australia U21 8000
Antonio Pereira GPRO River Senegal 8000
Martin Carson GPRO Man City (none) 7850
Elliot Hartfree-Pearce SI Wolfsburg England 7750
Jonathan Beagles GPRO Bochum Croatia 7500
Dan Reed GPRO PSG (none) 7300
Andy Taylor GPRO Udinese China 7300
Daniel Lewis OTF2 Genoa Chile 7200
Kashvinder Mann GPRO Everton (none) 7150
Toygun Senler GPRO Spurs (none) 7150
Janne Väänänen GPRO Monaco Finland 7100
Sid Venk SI Napoli (none) 7100
Kostas Farsalinos GPRO Athletic Greece 7000
Koen De Heldt GPRO AZ Belgium 7000
Ermin Covic GPRO Celtic (none) 7000
Halo Von Stromberg SI Rangers (none) 7000
Alex Hawkins GPRO Aston Villa (none) 6950
Maarten Verhulst GPRO FC Twente (none) 6900
Keith Addo-Dadzie FMBase Blackburn Ghana 6400
Occam Razero SI Portsmouth Canada 6400
Ben Cee SI Sunderland England U21 6350
Jouni Tolvanen GPRO Bolton Finland U21 6300
Gordon Ashford GPRO Newcastle (none) 6250
Kvothe SI Reading USA 6250
Stewart Robertson SI Wigan Scotland 6150
Tass Thorlu-Bangura FMBase Cardiff (none) 5200
Damian Weymouth SI Sheff Utd Togo 5200
Chris Williams GPRO Derby (none) 5150
Aleksandr Bismarck GPRO Ipswich (none) 5150
Samuel Tarry OTF2 Leicester (none) 5000
Adam Kerr SI Forest (none) 4950
Mark Webster GPRO Dundee Scotland U21 4900
Saxon Durrant GPRO Norwich Jamaica 4850
Andrei Ciuchi GPRO Inverness CT England U19 4600
Samoeni Albanalopolis GPRO (none) Albania 4550
Jake Stothard GPRO Doncaster Rovers Ghana U21 4500
Iain Bartholomew GPRO Ayr (none) 3650
Ax Macc GPRO (none) Singapore 2350

---------- Post added at 12:27 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:27 AM ----------

"Due to problems in the test game of managers retiring for being unemployed for too long, I've gone with a two-fold solution to this issue:

Firstly, I'm going to give everyone a 2nd nationality of either of the following:

Argentinian, Brazilian, Dutch, French, German, Italian, Portuguese, Scottish or Spanish. (Not English, as this is where many of the problems lie, I'm going to see if getting English managers abroad is possible)

If you've any preference then give me a shout. If you already have 2 nationalities, then no need to worry.

Secondly: I'm going to reduce the reputations so that sacked managers are more likely to go for other jobs. As it stands, an English big 4 manager when sacked will not even go for the Man City job when available. I will adjust the weighting of the handicaps when this is done. This will only affect those with a handicap of 7500 or more provisionally.

Cheers guys. :)"
 
Looks like the second nationalities weren't greatly needed.

Sorted out the retirement issues and have proposed this timetable of results.

1st March. Publishing of XML file and scoring system, Game 1 started.

15th March: Game 1 Results

29th March: Game 2 Results

12th April: Game 3 Results

26th April: Game 4 Results

10th May: Game 5 and final results.

I'll publish all games after completion, and I'll present results in GoogleDocs.

Hoping the patch comes out before then, to keep things consistent.

Good luck all!
 
Sorry but no, it's not my competition I'm just relaying this information :/
 
Scoring System:

Top Division League Win: +2,000 pts
Promotion gained: +1,000 pts
Major Domestic Cup Win: +1,000 pts (Cup that qualifies you for continental competition)
Minor Domestic Cup Win: +500 pts
Major Continental Win: +2,000 pts (CL or UEFA Cup etc.)
Minor Continetal Win: +1,000 pts (Super Cup, Recopa etc.)
Major International Win: +2,500 pts (World Cup, Euro Champ, Copa America, ACoN etc.)
Minor International Win: +1,250 pts (U21 competition win etc.)
Game Played: -2 pts per game (you'll see why later)
Senior Wins: 6 pts
Senior Draws: 2 pts
Senior Losses: -1 pts
Int. U21 Win: 3 pts
Int. U21 Draw: 1 pt
Int. U21 Loss: -2 pts
Players Bought (in £millions): -10 points per million
Players Sold (in £millions): 10 points per million
Goal Difference: 0.5 points per positive goal difference
Annual Managerial Award Won: +100 pts
Annual Managerial Award Runner Up/3rd place: +50 pts
Loyalty Bonus: TBC after longer test game
Resignation from a job: -500 pts
Sacked from a job: -1,000 pts
Get a new job: +500 pts
Become manager of your own country: +1,500 pts
Enter your national hall of fame: +1,000 pts per place in the top 10 (1st gets +10,000 pts)
 
Top