Ali Adnan is he a hit or miss?

[elyybourgess]

Recently I started a new save with Manchester United on FM15 and after some scouting done I found Ali Adnan (pictured below) and as we all know with Luke Shaw being well known as an injury prone in the game (as he is in real life sadly) would Ali Adnan be the best solution for Luke Shaw?
View attachment 313897
I sent Ali on loan to Twente since he needs to get a work permit in order to play with my team.

 

[tommyd150]

Luke Shaw hasn't been injured on any save I've seen and turns out a beast but that guy looks a good player to rotate with him for a good 10 year.