Are scouts rubbish

[header234]

Ever since the last fm when my scouts told me craig linfield was only average and he turned out to be awesome, i have been sceptical of them. And now they are at it again!! Thiago was supposed to be amazing but he s very poor, n diaye the same. Is it me? or is anyone else suspicious of their s ??
Also do spurs ever sell mr G Bale ?? they want £45 mill for him!!

 

[Zidave]

Ever since the last fm when my scouts told me craig linfield was only average and he turned out to be awesome, i have been sceptical of them. And now they are at it again!! Thiago was supposed to be amazing but he s very poor, n diaye the same. Is it me? or is anyone else suspicious of their s ??
Also do spurs ever sell mr G Bale ?? they want £45 mill for him!!

Offered him to me at Chelsea for £5.75m at the start of season 4 and the **** won't even discuss terms with me...

 

[Jake]

Maybe YOUR scout is poor.

A scout needs good stats in Judging ability and potential, as well as adaptability, determination, tactical knowledge and discipline. The scouts knowledge of the nation is also highly important.

 

[20MULVEY08]

The ideal sout will have good stats for judging player potential
ability
determination
adaptability

 

[header234]

thankyou for that observation mr hawking . obvioulsly i had nt thought of that

 

[Jake]

thankyou for that observation mr hawking . obvioulsly i had nt thought of that

Um, sarcasm helps no-one?

If you had thought of it then why are you moaning about scout reports...?

 

[GodCubed]

thankyou for that observation mr hawking . obvioulsly i had nt thought of that

You asked a question, someone gave up their time to answer it with no charge to you. You need to change your attitude.

 

[pokiuki123]

Ever since the last fm when my scouts told me craig linfield was only average and he turned out to be awesome, i have been sceptical of them. And now they are at it again!! Thiago was supposed to be amazing but he s very poor, n diaye the same. Is it me? or is anyone else suspicious of their s ??
Also do spurs ever sell mr G Bale ?? they want £45 mill for him!!

I suppose that the scout can only judge a players ability. He wouldn't be able to tell you if he would fit into your team, be suited to your league or play in your formation.

 

[TJD07]

Scouts scout players, they don't tell you how to use them.

Anyway, you shouldn't just go by what they say.
Have them watch them for 1-2 games, then a month or so later do it again also keep an eye on their team, watch who they play and how they play.

Mostly though, give them time and not everyone is suitable for your team.
I've signed Aguero and had him do nothing for a season and half then suddenly he starts burying goals constantly.


I signed bale for 34mil 89k a week wages.

 

[phil06]

Ever since the last fm when my scouts told me craig linfield was only average and he turned out to be awesome, i have been sceptical of them. And now they are at it again!! Thiago was supposed to be amazing but he s very poor, n diaye the same. Is it me? or is anyone else suspicious of their s ??
Also do spurs ever sell mr G Bale ?? they want £45 mill for him!!

if you mean the Thiago from Barcelona, he actually turns out quite good, or atleast he did on one of my saves whenever I had him... so I don't think it's a problem with the scouts.

If you doubt the opinion of one scout just have another 1-2 give you a scout report on the player.

And yes Bale may leave Spurs at some point, especially with the current bugs regarding transfers... had him offered to me for 6 million € a few times. Still involves a bit of luck obviously.