Here's what I think about the game:
STRENGHTS:
1.) The set piece creator is very good, much more detailed then fm's set piece setting.
2.) Training is more detailed, and you can whatch it, so you can see what is going wrong/right.
3.) Scouting is very detailed, and you can pay to expand your scouting knowledge.
4.) When you offer a player to clubs, you can offer him to one specific club instead of always having to offer him to all clubs in general.
WEAKNESSES:
1.) 3D match engine isn't as good as FM's.
2.) A lot of players are very over-priced, e.g. Messi's value is £75m, fat Ronaldo's is £5.5m etc.
3.) You can't get a team report.
4.) Coach/scout reports aren't as detailed.
OVERALL: I'd say it's a decent game, but fm is a lot better