David de gea or Victor Valdes

[Yoblackcat]

Im looking for a new keeper.Victor valdes is 32 now and david de gea is 23 Which one sud i go for ????????

 

[AldoKemp-1]

David De Gea of course. Much more ahead of him and is a tremendous goalkeeper already at a young age only to improve.

 

[Robwiks]

De Gea. For above reason.

 

[kris.b]

I'd have to say de Gea, just because of the age. From Valdes you can get some 3-5 seasons, while from De Gea 13-15.

Plus, De Gea is probably the best young goalkeeper in the game, only a regen might have better potential, so that's another reason right there.

And finally, I don't think the wages they'll ask are even comparable, with De Gea being by far a cheaper option.

 

[AldoKemp-1]

Only thing is you may have a problem prizing him away from athletico as he loves the club.

 

[potta]

I disagree, Victor Valdes will be hitting his potential ability right about now, so I would keep him and use Gea as back-up and play him in the ' unimportant fixtures'. De Gea will be class by the time Victor hits 34-35.

Any how you have two top class keepers

 

[cmh9090]

read this:

http://www.fm-base.co.uk/forum/f101/this-player-vs-that-player-t49788.html

please avoid making similar threads in future. compare the players' cost, age, potential and statistics and you will eventually decide on which one to get