Do macheda, petrucci and gibson turn out good?

[andriymel]

Do they turn out to be any good a few seasons later on? Because clubs wana buy em off, but its seems like a bad move because of their stats when their young. Also what other man utd youngsters should i keep?

 

[Jay Pricey]

Macheda turns out great. Gibson is never anything special and Petrucci is okay I guess, but from experience he always really wants a return to Italy.

 

[Irish Scouse]

Not really good enough for Man Utd in my experience. But i have never managed them personally, only the AI.

Edit: Macheda is a semi regular Juventus player, around 4th - 6th place in Serie A side. So decent. But there are much better out there. Loan them out for a season or 2.

 

[NUFC_Tony]

Gibson turns out rubbish on my saves, not worth the hassle really.

 

[alicwkd]

keep macheda, turns out class

 

[Jacksonrip]

Macheda and Petrucci I think scored over 15 goals each for Man Utd. in the 2015-2016 season in my save, so they turn out good, but Gibson will not become good enough for the premier league, probably good player for championship.

 

[HOT Hawkeye]

NAh

NAh not good, although i recommend Eden Hazard, Carlos Eduardo, Mario Balotelli, Luis Suarez

 

[Dowey09]

Gibson's not amazing but he's good for a squad player, I kept him and he chips in with around 5 goals a season when he does play which isn't often. Developed right, Petrucci becomes really good and Macheda's PA changes from game to game I think so whilst he is ocassionaly really god, he can often be quite poor. I usually sell him and welbeck and raise about 15-20 million between them.

 

[Raikan007]

Mechada - Awesome (definately keep)
Gibson - Useless (sell)
Petrucci - Good (was sold for 21 million in my save, not even that good stats)
​

 

[ok797]

does anyone know if obertan turns good because i have loaned him out for the last 2 seasons to sunderland and he has hardly done anything for them.

 

[Versaty1e]

I personally hang on to Cleverley before Gibson. Gibson is a squad player at United.

Macheda is amazing. Have Rooney tutor him and send him out on loan between the ages of 19 and 21 for first team experience.