Fellaini or Gündogan?

[ChrBr]

I want a deep lying playmaker for my United save, but can't really decide which player to choose. Fellaini or Gündogan?

Have been checking around for others aswell, all ideas are welcome

Note that I've already bought Vidal, so you can leave him out.

 

[xikito]

Gundogan all the way! Trust me

 

[Mikon]

Fellaini is not a deep lying playmaker, he's more of a ball winning midfilder with great CM stats as well.
Gundogan is great! Also look for Cabaye for this kind of player!

 

[tommyd150]

mario bolatti

 

[mekitozito]

Yann M'vila if DM. Perhaps Moutinho if CM.

 

[ruudvannovarroy]

I'm PSG and have scouted both in 1st season, Scout(kremer-ex leverkusen) gives fellaini 4 stars for current n potential ability, Gundogan 3,5 CA / 4,5 PA...
I decided to buy Fellaini, and I never regret buying him afer 1st season, consistent to play and got rating >7 every match...

 

[mwhitehorn07]

they play different roles.

Fellaini can play DM, and if you want, AMC, but not as a DLP.

Gundogan is perfect for the DLP role. Also, Denys Garmash is a MONSTER. Both are young and will need time to develop.

 

[Vanpersie1998]

Gundogan. Fellaini is BWM not DLP.

 

[mld81]

As already stated, Fellaini is a BWM. I have never bought Gundogan so cannot recommend him. Cabaye is a great choice but alternative options possibly could be Lorenzo Crisetig, Ole Kristian Selnæs or Albin Ekdal.