From Coast to Cup: A Mullion AFC Story

Joined
Sep 3, 2026
Messages
4
Reaction score
1
Points
1
ChatGPT Image Sep 3, 2026, 02_09_08 AM.webp




Chapter One: One Conversation

Michael Harconi had spent plenty of time telling professional football managers what they were doing wrong.

From the comfort of a sofa, it had always seemed relatively straightforward.

Why make that substitution?

Why play that formation?

Why leave that player on the bench?

The fact that Michael had never managed a football club, coached professionally or earned a single coaching badge had rarely stopped him having an opinion.

After all, he had played the game.

Well, sort of.

For five years, Michael had played Sunday League football, primarily on the right-hand side of midfield. There had been muddy pitches, questionable refereeing decisions and plenty of post-match conversations about what should have happened.

There had also been one particular moment that his former teammates were unlikely to let him forget.

A pass back from the halfway line.

An own goal.

From that distance.


It was not the moment that would earn Michael a professional contract.

Not that one had ever been expected.

By 2024, at the age of 31, Michael had decided to step away from Sunday League football altogether. His playing career had been about enjoyment, friendship and the occasional reminder that football was considerably more difficult when you were actually the one expected to kick the ball.

Management had never been part of the plan.

Then came a conversation in a pub.



The Conversation

It began as most football conversations do.

A disagreement.

Michael had found himself talking to a man named Darren Phillips. Neither had expected the evening to lead anywhere particularly significant.

Football was discussed.

Managers were criticised.

Tactics were questioned.

Michael, naturally, had a few opinions.

As the conversation continued, Darren mentioned something that caught Michael's attention. He was unhappy with the situation surrounding his football club and was considering making a change in the dugout.

By this point, Michael had been drinking.

And as the evening continued, his confidence in his own footballing knowledge appeared to increase at roughly the same rate as his alcohol consumption.

Eventually, Michael made a joke.

"I could do the job."

The problem was that Darren Phillips was not simply another football supporter enjoying an evening in the pub.

He was the chairperson of Mullion AFC.

And apparently, he was listening.

Somewhere between the football discussion, the drinks and Michael becoming increasingly convinced that he could manage a football club, a joke began to turn into something considerably more serious.

Michael Harconi had a job.

His first job in football management.

The two arranged to meet the following morning to discuss Mullion's vision, expectations and the future of the club.

Michael went home.

And, unfortunately, woke up the following morning with considerably less confidence than he had possessed the night before.



The Morning After

Michael woke up hungover.

His head hurt.

His mouth was dry.

And for several minutes, he had absolutely no recollection of agreeing to anything particularly important.

Then he checked his phone.

There was a message waiting.

Darren Phillips:

"Morning Michael. Where are you? You've missed the meeting."

Meeting?

Michael stared at the message.

Then, slowly, the events of the previous evening began to return.

The conversation.

The football club.

The drinks.

The joke.

The job.

The fact that he was now, somehow, the manager of Mullion AFC.

And, less than twenty-four hours into his managerial career, he had already missed his first meeting with the chairperson.

It was perhaps not the ideal start.

Still, there were plenty of football managers who had started their careers with less-than-perfect opening days.

Probably.



The Seagulls

Mullion AFC were not a club regularly discussed on national television.

There were no famous former players.

No major rivals.

No wealthy owners promising to transform the club overnight.

Mullion were an amateur football club with an obscure reputation, playing their football in the St Piran League Premier Division West.

Their home was Clifden Park.

Capacity: 1,000.

Seated capacity: 50.


The club had been founded in 1912 and had spent more than a century representing its community.

Now, in July 2025, a 32-year-old former Sunday League footballer with no coaching badges and no management experience had somehow been given the opportunity to take charge.

Chairperson Darren Phillips was not demanding miracles.

The expectation was simple.

A mid-table finish.

Mullion were predicted to finish eighth.

On paper, there was enough to work with.

The squad contained 22 first-team players, alongside four Under-21 players and seven Under-18 players. The centre of the pitch looked strong. There were options in attack.

The defence, however, was another question entirely.

Young.

Promising.

But inexperienced.


For a first-time manager who intended to play attacking football, it was hardly the most reassuring place to find the squad's biggest weakness.



The Harconi Way?

Michael did not arrive at Mullion with a folder full of coaching qualifications.

There was no carefully developed tactical philosophy built during years of coaching.

There was simply an idea of how football should be played.

Attack.

Use the width.

Take the game to the opposition.


Michael's preferred system would be a 4-3-2-1, with attacking football and wing play forming the basis of his plans.

Whether those plans would actually work was another matter.

After all, having an opinion about professional football managers from the sofa was one thing.

Being responsible for the team yourself was something entirely different.

Michael would now have to pick the players.

Choose the tactics.

Make the substitutions.

Explain the defeats.

And, hopefully, celebrate the victories.

Fortunately, Michael had already developed one management technique he was confident would work.

After a win, he would buy the pints.

Whether that was enough to inspire an amateur football team remained to be seen.



From Coast to Cup

Mullion was the beginning.

But the dream was bigger.

Cornwall has a proud footballing culture, with clubs, communities and supporters spread throughout the county. Yet when English football is discussed on the national stage, Cornwall rarely finds itself at the centre of the conversation.

Could that change?

Could one small amateur football club begin a journey through the English football pyramid?

Could Mullion AFC become something bigger than anyone currently expected?

Michael Harconi certainly had no idea how far the journey would go.

At this point, he was simply trying to survive his first week as a football manager.

But every journey has to start somewhere.

For Mullion AFC, it started at Clifden Park.

For Michael Harconi, it started with a conversation in a pub.

And somewhere between the Cornish coast and the biggest stages in English football, there was a very long road ahead.


The journey had begun.



Game: Football Manager 2026

Club: Mullion AFC

Starting League: St Piran League Premier Division West

Start Date: 7 July 2025

Manager: Michael Harconi

Database: DanFMDatabases E20 - England to Level 11

Club Status: Amateur

Club Reputation: Obscure

Predicted Finish: 8th

Board Expectation: Mid-table
 

FROM COAST TO CUP

The Mullion AFC Story

CHAPTER TWO: BEFORE THE FIRST WHISTLE



Michael Harconi had made it through his first morning as a football manager.

Barely.

The meeting with Darren Phillips had eventually been rearranged, the hangover had gradually disappeared and, more importantly, reality had finally started to sink in.

This was not a joke anymore.

There was no sofa.

There was no television.

There was no opportunity to shout at somebody else for making the wrong substitution.

Michael Harconi was now the person making the decisions.

And his first task was simple.

Work out exactly what he had inherited.



THE SQUAD

On first inspection, the situation at Mullion was not quite as disastrous as Michael had feared.

The club had a reasonable-sized first-team squad, with plenty of players available for the upcoming campaign.

There was also a clear pattern.

Youth.

Lots of it.

The squad was packed with young players, including a remarkable number of 16-year-olds who were now going to be asked to adapt to senior football.

There were experienced players around them, but this was clearly a squad with one eye on the future.

The centre of the pitch appeared to be one of Mullion's strongest areas.

There were options.

There was energy.

And there were players capable of creating opportunities.

Further forward, Mullion also had enough attacking talent to give Michael reasons for optimism.

The problem was at the other end.

Defensively, there were questions.

The defenders were young and potentially capable of developing into useful players.

Unfortunately, potential does not stop crosses.

Potential does not win headers.

And potential does not prevent a striker from running straight through the middle of your defence.

Still, Michael had always intended to play attacking football.

Perhaps the best form of defence really was attack.

He would soon find out.



THE GOALKEEPER SITUATION

Every football manager wants certainty between the posts.

Someone reliable.

Someone experienced.

Someone capable of organising the defence and dealing with the occasional moment of chaos.

Mullion's current first-choice goalkeeper was sixteen years old.

Reece Marchant.

At sixteen, Marchant was one of the youngest players in the first-team squad.

He also appeared to be the club's best goalkeeper.

That was either extremely encouraging for Reece Marchant.

Or deeply concerning for everybody else.

A closer look at his attributes produced some interesting reading.

Reflexes?

9.

Rushing out?

9.

Decisions?

9.

Strength?

1.

Michael was not entirely sure what to make of that final number.

There were some concerns elsewhere too.

Anticipation: 3.

Communication: 3.

Command of Area: 4.

Positioning: 4.

The youngster clearly had potential.

The question was whether Mullion could afford to learn alongside him.

Finding an alternative goalkeeper did not appear to be the biggest problem.

Finding goalkeepers was relatively easy.

Convincing them to actually join Mullion was another matter entirely.

The amateur football pyramid had a cruel reality.

You could identify a player.

You could speak to him.

You could convince him to agree to join.

And then a club one division above could appear and take him anyway.

Recruitment was going to be less about finding the best available player.

It was going to be about finding the best available player who actually wanted to play for Mullion AFC.



THE HARCONI WAY

Michael had arrived at Mullion with no coaching badges.

No coaching experience.

And absolutely no previous experience of managing a football club.

What he did have was an idea.

He wanted his team to attack.

He wanted to use the width.

And he wanted Mullion to take the game to their opponents.

The preferred formation would be a 4-3-2-1.

How strictly that would survive contact with reality remained to be seen.

Football Manager had a habit of making tactical ideas sound considerably more intelligent before the first match began.

Michael had spent years questioning professional managers from the outside.

Now it was his turn.

The difference was that there would be nowhere to hide.

If the formation failed, it was his formation.

If the substitutions failed, they were his substitutions.

And if the goalkeeper with Strength 1 got pushed over by a strong breeze, Michael would probably have to take some responsibility for that too.



PRE-SEASON: THE FIRST TEST

Before the league campaign could begin, Mullion had five opportunities to prepare.

Five matches.

Five chances to experiment.

Five opportunities for Michael to discover whether his tactical ideas were brilliant.

Or completely ridiculous.

Pre-Season Fixtures:

  • 9 July 2025 — Penzance (H)
  • 16 July 2025 — St Blazey (H)
  • 19 July 2025 — AFC St Austell (H)
  • 26 July 2025 — Gunnislake (A)
  • 30 July 2025 — Polperro (H)

The opening match against Penzance would be Michael's first opportunity to see his new team in action.

Results would matter.

Of course they would.

But pre-season was about more than winning football matches.

It was about finding combinations.

Testing players.

Trying different approaches.

And figuring out who could be trusted when the competitive fixtures finally arrived.

Five matches were not a lot of time.

But they were all Michael Harconi had.



THE LEAGUE CAMPAIGN

The competitive season would finally begin on the 23rd of August.

Mullion's first match would take them away to St Just.

One week later, the Seagulls would return to Clifden Park for their first home league match against St Agnes.

From there, the season would slowly build.

September would bring four league fixtures.

October would bring another four.

The campaign would continue through the Cornish autumn and winter before reaching its conclusion in April 2026.

The opening fixtures:

  • 23 August — St Just (A)
  • 30 August — St Agnes (H)
  • 6 September — Perranwell (A)
  • 13 September — St Day Reserves (H)
  • 20 September — Redruth United (A)
  • 27 September — Hayle (H)

The fixtures would eventually take Mullion through a twenty-two-match league campaign.

From St Just in August to St Ives Town in April, there was a long road ahead.

And at this stage, nobody really knew where Mullion would end up.



EXPECTATIONS

The board had made their expectations clear.

Finish mid-table.

The media prediction was slightly more specific.

8th place.

For a first-time manager, Michael had no real reason to argue.

He had not managed at this level before.

He had not watched most of these teams play.

He had not even completed his first pre-season match.

Making bold predictions would have been foolish.

Then again, Michael had acquired his first management job after making a drunken joke in a pub.

Perhaps foolishness had already played a small part in his career.

The target was mid-table.

The prediction was eighth.

The reality?

Nobody knew yet.




FIVE FRIENDLIES.

TWENTY-TWO LEAGUE MATCHES.

A SQUAD FULL OF YOUNG PLAYERS.

A DEFENCE THAT NEEDED WORK.

AND A SIXTEEN-YEAR-OLD GOALKEEPER WITH STRENGTH 1.




What could possibly go wrong?



Game: Football Manager 2026

Club: Mullion AFC

Starting League: St Piran League Premier Division West

Start Date: 7 July 2025

Manager: Michael Harconi

Database: DanFMDatabases E20 - England to Level 11

Club Status: Amateur

Club Reputation: Obscure

Predicted Finish: 8th

Board Expectation: Mid-table

Preferred Formation: 4-3-2-1

Playing Style: Attacking football with wing play
 

FROM COAST TO CUP

The Mullion AFC Story

CHAPTER THREE: A DIFFICULT START, A PROMISING END



Michael Harconi had now completed his first month in football management.

It had not been boring.

In fact, after five pre-season matches, several new signings and one increasingly questionable teenage goalkeeper situation, Harconi had learned considerably more about management than he ever had from shouting at professional football managers on television.

The most important lesson?

Football is considerably easier when somebody else is making the decisions.

July had been a difficult month.

But by the end of it, there was finally reason for optimism.



THE GOALKEEPER HUNT

The first major issue Michael identified at Mullion was the goalkeeper situation.

Reece Marchant was sixteen years old and, despite his obvious potential, some of his attributes suggested that putting him straight into the first team might be an adventurous decision.

So the solution was obvious.

Sign more sixteen-year-old goalkeepers.

Two trialists arrived at Clifden Park.

Luca Mareus and Tuler Kitson were both given the opportunity to prove themselves during pre-season.

Mareus played in the 3-2 defeat against St Blazey.

Kitson played against AFC St Austell.

Unfortunately for Kitson, the latter did not go particularly well.

Five shots on target.

Five goals conceded.

It was a trial that was memorable for all the wrong reasons.

Mareus, meanwhile, had done enough to impress.

Other clubs were interested, including teams playing above Mullion in the pyramid.

Fortunately, the trial system had worked in Mullion's favour.

Mareus had spent time with the squad.

He had played for the club.

And when the opportunity came to sign him permanently...

He chose Mullion AFC.



THE FIRST FRIENDLIES

Pre-season began against stronger opposition.

The opening fixture against Penzance ended in a 3-1 defeat, although Mullion had actually taken the lead before eventually being beaten.

The following match against St Blazey was even more encouraging.

Mullion fell behind 1-0 before fighting back to take a 2-1 lead.

Unfortunately, the higher-level opposition eventually turned the game around and claimed a 3-2 victory.

Then came AFC St Austell.

The final score was...

0-5.

The statistics, however, told a slightly different story.

Mullion were not completely dominated.

The expected goals were incredibly close.

Mullion created chances.

The problem was that Tuler Kitson's afternoon had been rather unfortunate.

Or disastrous.

Depending on your perspective.

Five shots on target.

Five goals conceded.

The search for a goalkeeper was officially over.



SAME LEVEL, DIFFERENT TEST

The fourth friendly took Mullion away to Gunnislake.

Unlike the previous opposition, Gunnislake played at the same level as Mullion in the St Piran League Premier Division East.

This was an important test.

The result was disappointing.

Gunnislake 1-0 Mullion.

But the performance gave Michael reasons for encouragement.

Mullion created the better quality opportunities and actually finished the match with a slightly higher expected goals total.

The Seagulls had also created the only clear-cut chance of the match.

The difference?

One goal.

The result meant Mullion had now lost all four pre-season matches.

However, the performances suggested that the situation was not quite as bad as the results made it appear.

Still, there was clearly work to do.



REBUILDING THE SQUAD

The opening friendlies had confirmed Michael's original assessment of the squad.

The midfield looked strong.

The attack had options.

The defence needed help.

So naturally, the first signing was a striker.

David Horgan joined Mullion at the age of nineteen.

With a finishing attribute of 14, he immediately offered an upgrade in the centre-forward position and fitted the system Michael wanted to play.

The defence would eventually receive some attention too.

Josh Sutton arrived to strengthen the left-back position.

Quick, determined and capable of contributing going forward, Sutton was signed to play as a traditional full-back.

Then came Adam Heaton.

Heaton was brought in primarily as a right-back but offered something equally valuable at this level.

Versatility.

Able to provide cover across the defensive line, he gave Mullion another option in an area of the squad that had been identified as a major weakness.

By the end of July, Michael had made four signings.

🧤 Luca Mareus — Goalkeeper

⚽ David Horgan — Striker

⬅️ Josh Sutton — Left-Back

➡️ Adam Heaton — Right-Back / Defensive Cover

The squad was beginning to change.



THE PERFECT WAY TO END JULY

After four consecutive defeats, Mullion welcomed Polperro to Clifden Park.

Like Gunnislake, Polperro competed in the St Piran League Premier Division East.

This was another opportunity to see where Mullion really stood against teams at their own level.

And this time...

Everything clicked.


🔴⚪ MULLION AFC 4-1 POLPERRO 🔴⚪

After the frustration of the previous friendlies, Mullion finally produced the performance Michael had been waiting for.

4 goals.

8 shots on target.

2.32 xG.

3 clear-cut chances.


The standout performer was Lukas Quasi, who produced an outstanding performance.

More importantly, Mullion finally looked like a team that could compete.

The earlier defeats had exposed weaknesses.

The recruitment work had started to address them.

And now, with the league season approaching, the Seagulls had finished July with their best result of pre-season.



JULY 2025 — THE NUMBERS



PLAYED: 5

WON: 1

DRAWN: 0

LOST: 4

GOALS SCORED: 7

GOALS CONCEDED: 13


The record does not look particularly impressive.

And if you only looked at the results, you would probably be concerned.

But football rarely tells the whole story through results alone.

The opening fixtures came against stronger opposition.

The squad weaknesses were exposed.

New players arrived.

And Mullion finished the month with a convincing victory against opposition from their own level.

The season had not even started yet.

But Michael Harconi had already learned an important lesson.

Sometimes, losing pre-season matches tells you exactly what you need to know.




NEXT UP...

AUGUST 2025

Two more pre-season fixtures remain.

🏠 RNAS Culdrose

✈️ Saltash United Reserves

Then...

THE REAL THING BEGINS.

23rd August 2025.

St Just vs Mullion AFC.


From Coast to Cup officially begins.

🔴⚪🕊️



Game: Football Manager 2026

Club: Mullion AFC

League: St Piran League Premier Division West

Level: 11

Manager: Michael Harconi

Start Date: 7 July 2025

Database: DanFMDatabases E20 - England to Level 11

Club Status: Amateur

Club Reputation: Obscure

Board Expectation: Mid-table

Media Prediction: 8th

Preferred Formation: 4-3-2-1

Playing Style: Attacking football with wing play
 
FROM COAST TO CUP
Chapter Three: Favourites? Apparently.

August 2025



When I arrived at Mullion, the expectation was fairly simple.

Mid-table.

The media had us predicted to finish eighth. The board wanted us somewhere comfortably in the middle. For a bloke with no coaching badges, no management experience and whose route into the job began with a drunken conversation in a pub, that sounded perfectly reasonable.

Then we started signing players.

Apparently, that was a mistake.

Because somewhere between rebuilding the defence and trying to put together a squad capable of playing the football I wanted, the media completely lost their minds.

Mullion AFC were suddenly predicted to finish first.

Not just first, either.

We were now the odds-on favourites to win the league.

Seven Mullion players appeared in the media's Dream XI.

Seven.

I hadn't even managed a competitive game yet.

No pressure, then.



Finishing Pre-Season

July had ended with our best performance of pre-season, a 4-1 win against Polperro.

We carried that into August with one final home friendly against RNAS Culdrose.

Mullion 1-0 RNAS Culdrose

It took until the 92nd minute, but K. Bastin finally found the goal our performance deserved.

We had 15 shots to their four and restricted Culdrose to just 0.08 xG.

It wasn't spectacular.

It was, however, another win.

Two victories in a row.

Maybe we were learning.

Two days later we travelled to Saltash United Reserves for the final friendly.

Saltash United Reserves 1-0 Mullion

We lost, but it wasn't exactly a disaster. We had 13 shots, six on target and plenty of the ball.

Pre-season was over.

There had been some horrible moments — the 5-0 defeat against St Austell certainly wasn't going in the scrapbook — but there had also been signs that the squad was beginning to take shape.

Now it actually mattered.



Building Harconi's Mullion

The squad rebuild continued throughout August.

My aim remained simple: a first-team squad of 23, with two properly designated players for every position — four centre-backs and four defensive midfielders because the system uses two of each — plus three goalkeepers.

No padding the numbers by pretending somebody who can occasionally play somewhere counts as the designated backup.

If you're my right-back, you're a right-back.

If you're my centre-back, you're a centre-back.

It turns out building a perfectly balanced squad at an amateur football club is considerably easier to explain than actually do.

Josh Sutton arrived for the left-back position.

Adam Heaton came in at right-back.

Then came the centre-backs.

Callum Lock.

Mickey Archibald.

Nick Milton.


And John Elliott, a 19-year-old Canadian who has plenty of potential but isn't quite ready for the first team yet, so he has gone into the U21s to develop.

There was a slight problem with the centre-back recruitment.

I'd approached several players because getting anybody to agree to join an amateur club at this level can be a nightmare.

They all agreed.

Lesson learned.

Probably.

Further forward, Callum Thomas joined the defensive midfield group and Benji Hall arrived as an attacking midfielder.

Then came Dean Billingsley.

The 29-year-old striker joined David Horgan as our two designated centre-forwards.

The squad was getting stronger.

There were still obvious holes — particularly out wide — but we were getting there.



St Just 1-0 Mullion
St Piran League Premier Division West
23 August 2025​

And so it began.

My first competitive match as a football manager.

Away at St Just.

The media might have decided we were going to win the league, but St Just apparently hadn't received the memo.

They had 67% of the possession and made us spend long periods without the ball.

But we weren't being destroyed.

In fact, we had 14 shots to their 12.

Both teams put five on target.

And our xG was actually higher: 1.56 to 1.24.

The problem?

They scored.

We didn't.

A. Fagan put St Just ahead three minutes after half-time and that was enough.

FULL TIME: St Just 1-0 Mullion

Welcome to competitive management, Michael.

The biggest concern wasn't necessarily the result.

It was the system.

I want Mullion playing attacking football with width.

There's one fairly obvious requirement for playing good wing play:

Good wingers.

We don't currently have them.

Turns out tactics work better when you have footballers capable of doing the things you've asked them to do.

Who knew?



Mullion 1-1 St Agnes
St Piran League Premier Division West
30 August 2025​

Our first home league game.

Clifden Park holds 1,000 people.

About 50 turned up.

Twenty season tickets suddenly didn't seem quite as insignificant as they had a few weeks earlier.

And after 23 minutes, they had something to celebrate.

Dean Billingsley — 23 minutes.

On his debut.

And it was another new signing who created it, with Benji Hall providing a superb assist.

Billingsley had his first Mullion goal.

Hall had his first Mullion assist.

And I had my first competitive lead as a manager.

We took that 1-0 advantage into half-time.

For 65 minutes, it looked like the first victory might be coming.

Then St Agnes were awarded a penalty.

They scored.

Mullion 1-1 St Agnes.

And that's how it finished.

Not the home win we'd wanted, but our first point of the season was on the board.

Played 2. Won 0. Drawn 1. Lost 1.

One point from six.

Hardly the start expected from the supposed odds-on title favourites.

But I'm not panicking.

Yet.



The Search Continues

Two competitive matches have reinforced something that was already becoming obvious.

We need wingers.

Proper ones.

The recruitment search has already produced one particularly interesting possibility.

Tyler Pierre.

The 21-year-old can play on the right side of attacking midfield and is currently with Porthleven's U21s.

Porthleven currently sit top of the division.

Pierre, however, isn't getting a look-in with their first team.

At Mullion?

There is a vacant shirt waiting for him.

An offer has been made.

Now we wait.

Two games into the season, the league table doesn't look how the media predicted it would.

That's fine.

Nobody ever won a league in August.

And nobody ever built a football club in eight weeks.

The squad is better than the one I inherited.

The defence has been rebuilt.

Billingsley has scored on debut.

Hall already has an assist.

And somewhere amongst all of this, I'm starting to think we might actually have a football team.

We just need some ****** wingers.

August Record

Friendly:
Mullion 1-0 RNAS Culdrose
Saltash United Reserves 1-0 Mullion

League:
St Just 1-0 Mullion
Mullion 1-1 St Agnes

League Record: P2 W0 D1 L1 | 1 Point

To be continued...
 
Back
Top