has anyone ever won an appeal?

[pricey]

i have never won one is that the same for everyone else?

 

[Robbo]

Nope never

 

[pricey]

what is the point of having it on there then?

 

[FTMjonno]

I have won several for kids from Brazil and Argentina in season two. Usually for under 21s.

 

[JDY]

if you lose the appeal , do they make the ban even longer ?

 

[JP Woody]

They usually make the ban longer anyway i think,especially for violent conduct.Ive never won an appeal either,in fact ive stopped bothering.

 

[PhilT]

I have won them quite alot. weird

 

[ghosta]

i win alot..... haven't got a reduction in 09 yet though

 

[GazFtw]

never won one
just taken to fining player 2 weeks wages automatically
in the hope that keeping some discipline will stop me from having to appeal
the thought of getting sent off and not having a ban is just too much for me.

 

[Watzi99]

i have never won one is that the same for everyone else?

yeah only once though, if u ever want to win an appeal u need to go on to the match report and see what the commentator says about the incident. if he says it was harsh the go for it you should win

 

[mitchayo]

i had a 2 match ban lifted belleti (for man city) cleared the ball so normaly and drogba was standing behind him belletti got sent off i apealed and won

 

[Andy]

Definately never one. It annoys me when the comentator says its harsh but u still dont win

 

[AldoKemp-1]

I have won only a couple. it is possible but doesn't usually happen. - if your appealing all the time though it is just going to be thrown out the window by the FA or whatever.

 

[hibberd19]

Never won one ever! And then the ban gets extended with a failed appeal so its pretty annoying

 

[nuttywray]

try going to back to the match report and looking at the incident, then you can justify either to appeal or fine the player.

Usaully its the player fault so i fine them and they usually understand and play much better and more behaved.

 

[Propagandalf]

Yeah.... Ones, de Rossi made i GIANT freekick and got a red card... Then i (by accident) appealed the disicion... AND WON!! A little weird cuz' it was defenitly worth a 3 day suspension....