Just wanted to update this one last time. I'm now using the 4-1-2-1-2 narrow diamond about 80-90% of the time with amazing results. The only time I don't use this formation is if the opponent is throwing a 4-5-1 V at me. I didn't want to use the narrow diamond before because it lacked width and I thought that 4-4-2 classic and 4-2-3-1 would exploit its lack of width. At least in this game, that scenario is not the case. I'm well on my way to an EPL title and perhaps a Champions Cup title as well!