The reason why i wanted to bring the est values of clubs in is because the game Is wrong purely based on comparisons with one team to another. Perfect example is man city have a higher value than utd, I'm not a Utd fan.
This isn't possible, everyone who has commented has answered that by all the things they have said that are and are not included in the valuation of any club.
Well just purely on the commerciality of Utd there is no way City can be valued higher. All they have is a rich owner, that does not make any club worth more. That is one guys wealth not the clubs.
So if we disagree on the players being assets or not and debts playing a part, this is purely debate for the game. However what is clear that the value of the clubs in FM is wrong, by a long way and I just think that Si go for the easy and simple way. It's just a case of using these external valuations and putting them into the game.
You stay classy......