I've been working in direct style for some time, and I can safetly say its a bad formation to play direct, direct is about strikers creating chances for themselves, while the rest of team stay behind the ball. The formation you using favors possession to create chances in many ways. I recommend something with defensive wingers and full backs if they are reliable defenders 4-4-2, otherwise use 3-5-2. Strikers with attack duty, preferably strong/tall + fast/dribbler. A lone Advanced forward or poacher also work well if you have a tall Attacking Midfielder (AMC/ST) to play 4-4-1-1.