This has been happening to a bunch of others, the forums have abundants reports of this. I guess I'll save before each cup match and if there's a drawn and penalties go wrong like this I'll replay until whoever wins right. Unless the same happens in both directions and in a, let's say, logical way, meaning the 'wrong' result is not 'wrong', meaning you see your high penalty takers get all in and your mighty goalie stop them then the victory is given to the team with **** penalty takers and **** goalie., in which case I might consider replaying them anyways whenever there's no coincidence.