Rulli or Scuffet?

[adan1907]

I am playing on a create a club save which was based on Stoke, but I got rid of a lot of average players and brought in a lot of players with high potential.

One of those was Geronimo Rulli, who is now 25 and is playing well. I have just started the 2017/18 season and the transfer window is still open, and I keep getting a lot of offers for Rulli for about £23m. I'm keen to keep hold of him given how good he is, but I am also very keen on Scuffet, and would love to make him part of the squad.

Rulli is better at the moment as he is more developed, but I want to know whether Scuffet is worth bringing in young before his price rockets, and whether he would hold his own if he was my No.1 keeper and I sold Rulli.

Any comments (productive) welcome! Thanks

 

[MANUMAD]

Well Rulli is great. There is no reason to sell him once you have him really. Yes Scuffet may develop to be slightly better but I wouldnt get him. Id get somebody younger and cheaper like Rajkovic to have him as backup to Rulli

 

[Cryus]

You can push the price for Rulli up to around 40 mil. 30-33 right now and 7 over 5 games int. 25% of next sale is also easy to get incl. Rajkovic is more often a better choise in england then scuffet, schuffet takes alot more time to get ready for PL.

 

[Jden86]

100% keep Rulli, once you have him, he's settled, don't stuff with the team to get 1% better. Plus 23mil you'll make Scuffet will cost more, plus bonuses, end up being expensive GK.

 

[woolly]

Keep Rulli, I managed to get him on a free in 2016/17 season as a back up for De Gea and didn't have any problems with him. Reluctantly sold him on for £25 million up front and several clauses to PSG a season later as I didn't see him taking over as number 1 at Man U and he wanted game time. However, he is definitely premiership quality and settles immediately.