Shay Given or Manuel Neuer (1st season)

[Sumner_05]

just started with arsenal and sold alumnia, i am unsure whether to go for shay given or manuel neuer.

however i could afford both

which player do you think is more effective?

 

[raul93-fan]

IMO you should go with Neuer. He is more expensive than Shay given, but he's younger, and is a awesome signing.

If I were you, I'd go with Neuer, but wait for a few more opinions and then choose

 

[Sumner_05]

IMO you should go with Neuer. He is more expensive than Shay given, but he's younger, and is a awesome signing.

If I were you, I'd go with Neuer, but wait for a few more opinions and then choose

cheers mate, yer will wait for a couple more comments

 

[mekitozito]

Manuel Neuer,no question.Hes +/- the same and much younger.Should also be cheaper.

 

[StuW]

Neuer. Younger, better, a lot more economic all round cash-wise.

 

[Sumner_05]

Neuer. Younger, better, a lot more economic all round cash-wise.

alrite cheers mate, just made an offer of £15 million for him