Spreadsheet System - Best Rated Team/Players


Destroyer Of Ego's
Jan 15, 2009
Reaction score
Following on from my ongoing thread here: http://www.fm-base.co.uk/forum/foot...imulation-spreadsheet-system.html#post1764722 I have decided to take a look at each spreadsheet and put together a team for each division completed so far based on a 4-1-2-2-1 formation and 7 subs. Each player then has their respective positional rating out of 100. Please note that the five ratings relates to five key attributes only, and does not differentiate between age or potential, nor does it take into account things such as fitness and stamina, it is based on pure ability.

Does it tally with the players you feel are the best or try to sign? Are there any surprises? Unsurprisingly, the Scottish Premier League team is littered with Celtic players. The Premier League one looks even stranger, Gareth Bale wouldn't even make the bench. If nothing else, it has given food for thought with Rabiu Ibrahim, he could be one **** of an Attacking Midfielder.

English Premier League

GK: Joe Hart 83 - Man City
RB: Branislav Ivanovic 77 - Chelsea
LB: Ashley Cole 81 - Chelsea
CB: Per Mertesacker 89 - Arsenal
CB: Vincent Kompany 84 - Man City
DM: Sandro** 78 - Tottenham
CM: Paul Scholes 85 - Man Utd
AM: David Silva 92 - Man City
LW: Juan Mata 82 - Chelsea
RW: Nani 80 - Man Utd
ST: Robin Van Persie 84 - Man Utd

GK: Wojciech Szczesny 79 - Arsenal
FB: Phil Neville 77 - Everton
CB: Nemanja Vidic 82 - Man Utd
DM: Lucas Leiva** 77 - Liverpool
CM: Frank Lampard 83 - Chelsea
LW: Eden Hazard 78 - Chelsea
ST: Sergio Aguero 83 - Man City

** Vincent Kompany rates higher than both Sandro & Leiva in the DM position but is already used at Centre-Back.

Scottish Premier League

GK: Fraser Forster 73 - Celtic
RB: Mikael Lustig 70 - Celtic
LB: Gary Naismith 65 - Aberdeen
CB: Andy Webster 73 - Hearts
CB: Kelvin Wilson 67 - Celtic
DM: Victor Wanyama 70 - Celtic
CM: Ian Vigurs 70 - Ross County
AM: Rabiu Ibrahim 77 - Kilmarnock
RW: Gary Mackay-Steven 80 - Dundee Utd
LW: Georgios Samaras 69 - Celtic
ST: Gary Hooper 73 - Celtic

GK: Darren Randolph 69 - Motherwell
FB: Dave Mackay 64 - St Johnstone
CB: Thomas Rogne 67 - Celtic
DM: James Fowler 66 - Kilmarnock
CM: Joe Ledley 68 - Celtic
LW: Graham Carey 66 - St Mirren
ST: Lassad 69 - Celtic

Rabiu Ibrahim - Kilmarnock
View attachment 349918
Last edited:
Maths was never my strongest point, but im pretty sure that the prem squad has 12 players in it
You were right, it obviously wasn't a strong point for me either.