I doubt it will happen but I've been itching to say it for ages and after that Bolton win I had to put something on paper.
The case for David Luiz as the holding player in a 4-2-3-1.
+ His tendency to make fairly large mistakes every few games.
You're probably thinking: “Why the **** is this a strength?” and you'd be right to. This little idea is based around the fact that Luiz is clearly a skilled player and, given the state of other areas of the squad, is not someone who can just be cast aside so he needs to find a role somewhere.
With that in mind, putting him in CM means that when he makes stupid mistakes or poor tackles, he is unlikely to be sent off, concede a penalty or gift the opponent a goal. His poor decision in the recent game against Napoli was one in a long string of high profile gaffes from Sideshow Bob and I feel that to get the best out of him, he needs to be playing in a position that can mitigate his weaknesses, as well as emphasise his strengths.
+ His tight marking
When he first came to Chelsea, one of the most noticeable, and praised, aspects of Luiz's game was the way that he stuck to his man like a shadow. Chelsea have been lacking this sort of suppression in their game for most of the season: Mikel is quite honestly not that good at it, Meireles is shocking at it and Romeu is still learning. If you look at the 3-3 vs United, Rooney was able to cause havoc playing as a false nine, dropping deep and sitting in-between the defence and midfield. With someone like Luiz playing as a midfielder, he would not have been allowed that sort of time or space.
Think about it, how many times have you see someone sneak in this season because Meireles has given up tracking them?
+ His speed.
A much underrated trait in a holding player, it means that unlike Mikel, Luiz will be able to close down players effectively, without having to surrender too much space infront of the back 4.
+ His tendency to get forward
At first, this might seem like more a weakness than a strength for a holding player but you have to consider 2 things:
1. We're trying to find a solution to Luiz's role in the squad, so his forward runs are better suited to this position than to CB and of equal use to that of a FB. (Although I think being a fullback would negate many of Luiz's other strengths)
2. This idea assumes that, like in the Bolton game, Ramires will be willing to pitch in defensively and the double pivot will be a fairly fluid one, justlike AVB wanted. If that happens, having Luiz receiving the ball with the space and time he would get from starting deep, combined with the flexibility of having a pair of CMs that occasionally swap roles,will really help to make us a fluid side.
+His brain.
Yes, he does have one. Luiz makes 3 interceptions a game, a number only beaten in theChelsea squad by Gary Cahill. If you move him into midfield, he will have a chance to use that ability more and break up play with smart movement as well as strong tackling.
+ His passing
This is a big one. Luiz completes almost as many longballs as Cech, plays as many incisive through balls as Juan Mata and in the game against Bolton we saw him do a passable impression of Andrea Pirlo: picking out players much further up the pitch and continuously causing problems from deep. We're lacking so much penetration at the moment, it only seems logical to bring one of our more creative players into a position where he can have more influence on the game.
+ Work rate
Luiz always looks enthused and energetic in a Chelsea shirt, and together with Ramires we could have a real workhorse of a platform, allowing us to play luxury players like Moura in the 3.
The case against David Luiz as the holding player in a 4-2-3-1.
- His composure on the ball.
We all got a stark reminder of the dangers of playing out from the back earlier this season when Mikel dawdled and lost possession right in front of the back four, practically handing Liverpool the chance on a plate. Teams have already discovered that pressing us persistently causes all sorts of problems and I suspect Luiz would come under a lot of pressure if he were to move into CM.
- Lack of options
This is an extension of the first point really, but whereas that highlights the difficulty we could face if Luiz is pressured during the recycling of possession,this is more of an immediate issue. Assuming that the keeper plays it short, where will the defender pass? You'd assume to the fullback or to either of the central midfielders. A pairing of Ramires and Luiz leaves us with a fairly jittery foundation to base our attacks on, and if Mata (or whoever is in the hole) has to come very deep to offer them a short option, his effectiveness will be greatly reduced.
- Squad needs
If he can be learn to keep his head, Luiz will be an incredible defender and that is something we desperately need, whereas we have Romeu, Mikel, Essien, potentially McEachran (although he would be a DLP if not playing in AM), Ramires and Meireles all vying for a spot in midfield.
(Other things)
. The obvious solution to the first 2 problems is to play Luiz and a Deep Lying Playmaker at the base of the midfield, offering us flexibility, a number of creative outlets and stability. The problem with that is Ramires. Personally, I think Ramires could be a great player on the right hand side of the 3 but that all depends on how Sturridge turns out.
. If Essien returns to his previous levels, the holding spot will surely be his.