The Deal or No Deal Thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Dan
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 2K
  • Views Views 210K
Player:Andrea Poli
Team Buying: Manchester United
Teeam Selling: Sampdoria
Season 2013/14 (start of season)
Asking price: 15mil+ (i think i could make them lower the price a bit)
Ive got a maximum of 15mil to spend (as i spent it all on aguero) Is he better then Carrick?
Deal Or No Deal
 
I can't say deal or no deal, but I don't think he is better than Carrick. I don't know if this varies from game to game, but in my game he is not. He has better technical attributes (or the potential to have them) but only if you plan to use him as an MC. As a DMC, his marking, tackling are lower than Carrick and his heading/jumping is pitiful.

EDIT: Its 2013-14, so he might be better than Carrick. It depends on the position you wish to play him. As an MC, definitely Poli is better IMO. As a DMC, I think not.
 
Last edited:
What about Defour is he better then Poli??

NEED TO KNOW ABOUT TO SIGN ONE OF THEM CLUBS BOTH AGREED A DEAL!!!
 
Last edited:
I would go for Defour. I signed him on a free transfer at the beginning of the 2013-14 season for my ManU side and I play him instead of Carrick and Fletcher whom I use as subs.

Poli's technique, corners, finishing and dribbling and even passing are better than Defour but in terms of mental stats, there is no comparison. Defour is also my captain as he has got great determination, influence, team work and work rate. Plus, he is also very consistent. Not much of a contest, IMO :)

EDIT: None of them fit the DMC bill, IMO. Use them as MCs.
 
I just finished my first season as West Ham United and finished somehow 5th so i have alot of interest in alot of my main players Jack Collison is wanted by a few clubs and as soon as i reject he is leaving he comes out saying he wants to move as he feels hes acheived all he can at the clubs so the point of this is how much should i ask for i though 11,500,000 is a good enough as well as 30% of the sell on the next sale
 
jaydencollins said:
Player:Andrea Poli
Team Buying: Manchester United
Teeam Selling: Sampdoria
Season 2013/14 (start of season)
Asking price: 15mil+ (i think i could make them lower the price a bit)
Ive got a maximum of 15mil to spend (as i spent it all on aguero) Is he better then Carrick?
Deal Or No Deal
Click to expand...

Deal, beyond doubt !
 
Player: Sami Khedira
Team Buying: Liverpool (Me)
Teeam Selling: Real Madrid
Season; 2010/2011
Asking price: 4.5M
Deal Or No Deal
 
Player : Franck Ribery
Team Buying : Man U (they)
Team selling : Bayern (me)
Season 2010/2011
Price offered : 66 mil
Deal or no deal?
 
Season: 5th
Team Buying: Cardiff City (me)
Team Selling: Valencia
Player: Maduro
Fee: FREE
Deal or No Deal?

Season: 5th
Team Buying: Cardiff City (me)
Team Selling: Corinthians
Player: Gerson
Fee: £10.5m
Deal or No Deal?

Season: 5th
Team Buying: Cardiff City (me)
Team Selling: Boca
Player: Munoz (CB)
Fee: £7.5m
Deal or No Deal?

Season: 5th
Team Buying: Cardiff City (me)
Team Selling: Fulham
Player: Kaboul
Fee: £6m
Deal or No Deal?

Season: 5th
Team Buying: Cardiff City (me)
Team Selling: Newcastle
Player: Matt Mills
Fee: £3.6m
Deal or No Deal?

As you might be able to tell, I'm having trouble at CB!!!!
 
Season: 2010/2011
Team Buying: Liverpool (Me)
Team Selling: Galatasaray
Player: Arda Turan
Fee: £2.5M + Joe Cole
Deal or No Deal?
 
asanovic10 said:
Season: 5th
Team Buying: Cardiff City (me)
Team Selling: Valencia
Player: Maduro
Fee: FREE
Deal or No Deal?

Season: 5th
Team Buying: Cardiff City (me)
Team Selling: Corinthians
Player: Gerson
Fee: £10.5m
Deal or No Deal?

Season: 5th
Team Buying: Cardiff City (me)
Team Selling: Boca
Player: Munoz (CB)
Fee: £7.5m
Deal or No Deal?

Season: 5th
Team Buying: Cardiff City (me)
Team Selling: Fulham
Player: Kaboul
Fee: £6m
Deal or No Deal?

Season: 5th
Team Buying: Cardiff City (me)
Team Selling: Newcastle
Player: Matt Mills
Fee: £3.6m
Deal or No Deal?

As you might be able to tell, I'm having trouble at CB!!!!
Click to expand...

I'll say deal for the first 3, no deal to Kaboul and i'm not sure about the last one.
 
Season: 2009/2010
Team Buying: AC Milan (Me)
Team Selling: Wolfsburg
Player: Edin Dzeko
Fee: 24.5 Million upfront + 24.5 Million over 48 monthly installments.
 
Lord_Slop said:
Season: 2009/2010
Team Buying: AC Milan (Me)
Team Selling: Wolfsburg
Player: Edin Dzeko
Fee: 24.5 Million upfront + 24.5 Million over 48 monthly installments.
Click to expand...

No deal i say 49m£ is really too high you can buy Agüero for that money.

Also, Dzekoe gets unhappy and wants to be in transfer list sometimes
 
Lord_Slop said:
Season: 2009/2010
Team Buying: AC Milan (Me)
Team Selling: Wolfsburg
Player: Edin Dzeko
Fee: 24.5 Million upfront + 24.5 Million over 48 monthly installments.
Click to expand...

****** ****, no deal. You can get Dzeko for £22m, up front or over monthly instalments.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

FMBase

Beta

Resources

Back
Top