The 'Rate My Kit' Thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Jake
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 4K
  • Views Views 1M
Status
Not open for further replies.
peskybendben said:
Really nice Fonzie, 10/10.

Chelsea set using the new Z'12 template, which I :wub:

Ily7S.png


And you could argue that Adidas stripes don't go with an Umbro logo, but when I added the stripes, I didn't even notice they were identical to Adidas ones. Oh well, I like the kits still.
Click to expand...

My pick of the 3 was this one above, I think the stripes kinda work with Umbro 9/10 you mentioned the 'Z'12 template' how can i get hold of this template?
 
AlexanderKruseBerg said:
Here's my entry for the KOTW.
Not so sure about the away though (and is it against the rules to use a different logo?).
Home - Away
CeltichomeKOTW18.png
CelticawayKOTWalternate18.png

Feedback/Rates?
Click to expand...

Really like these, certainly got my vote on KOTW. 9.5/10 from me overall. :)
 
jmoser said:
Well It is not a kit but I thought it would be helpful to kitmakers so I'll post it here.
Made the arsenal anniversary crest because a proper png seems hard to come by. I'm not going to lie and say I drew this all from scratch, I just tried to make a more easily accessible and better quality version than what can be found on google images so far. Feel free to use it.

arsenalanniversarycrestbg.png
Click to expand...

Where did you get that from mate? It's perfect! Cheers.
 
I just took it off of this picture just in an attempt to have a high quality version. All I really did was make it more accessible and easy to use. I also have a version with a transparent background which might be even easier to use, I'll get around to uploading it.
 
jmoser said:
I just took it off of this picture just in an attempt to have a high quality version. All I really did was make it more accessible and easy to use. I also have a version with a transparent background which might be even easier to use, I'll get around to uploading it.
Click to expand...

Ah fair enough, nice find. I couldn't get it anywhere. There's a video on arsenal.com with the new kit and there's a close-up of the badge; I just print screened at that moment and make some tweaks XD
 
Harriers09 said:
My entry for kit of the week:



View attachment 168348View attachment 168349

rates and feedback would be greatly appreciated!
Click to expand...

They're solid kits nice job. I don't really like the scratchy paint brush strokes at the top of the away kit, but that is just my opinion. Also the extra large faded badge look seems to be getting used a lot lately, you did it well, but it is not my favorite style. I can't really fault the home except for maybe the adidas stripes on the sleeves. The way they stop and then start up again is kind of strange. But these are all just my opinion. I think technically they are very well done.
 
jmoser said:
They're solid kits nice job. I don't really like the scratchy paint brush strokes at the top of the away kit, but that is just my opinion. Also the extra large faded badge look seems to be getting used a lot lately, you did it well, but it is not my favorite style. I can't really fault the home except for maybe the adidas stripes on the sleeves. The way they stop and then start up again is kind of strange. But these are all just my opinion. I think technically they are very well done.
Click to expand...


Cheers for that. I actually agree with what you're saying. The home strip i wanted the stripes to be just on the white bits but i think it kinda looks like the green bit has been thrown on top, which it hasnt. I actually took me a bit of time getting it all lined up!

And yea the away kits, i do really like the big emblem on this but it has been done a lot i think. I do think the paint stripes at the top might look a little out of place but I thought I needed something there because it was looking a little bare.

Cheers anyway for getting back to me, appreciate it....Its how i learn :P
 
Harriers09 said:
Cheers for that. I actually agree with what you're saying. The home strip i wanted the stripes to be just on the white bits but i think it kinda looks like the green bit has been thrown on top, which it hasnt. I actually took me a bit of time getting it all lined up!

And yea the away kits, i do really like the big emblem on this but it has been done a lot i think. I do think the paint stripes at the top might look a little out of place but I thought I needed something there because it was looking a little bare.

Cheers anyway for getting back to me, appreciate it....Its how i learn :P
Click to expand...

Yeah no problem. I like to try to give feedback because I personally find it more useful than just a simple #/10 rating. And yeah, that is why I said the kits are technically well done. It seems to me that they came out looking exactly how you wanted them to come out, and for that reason I can't really fault them. Those couple of things I pointed out are just completely opinion based.
 
jmoser said:
Yeah no problem. I like to try to give feedback because I personally find it more useful than just a simple #/10 rating. And yeah, that is why I said the kits are technically well done. It seems to me that they came out looking exactly how you wanted them to come out, and for that reason I can't really fault them. Those couple of things I pointed out are just completely opinion based.
Click to expand...

I appreciate it. That's wonderful .Yes, you're totally right. The Kits gave me a lot of informations. And it's really well done. I'm willing to come here and see the forums.
 
These are my entries for KoTW. Any rates?

Celtichome.png
Celticaway.png
 
iamauser said:
These are my entries for KoTW. Any rates?

Celtichome.png
Celticaway.png
Click to expand...

Maybe it is just me, but I don't like the pattern on the home. IMHO that pattern looks better when used in a slightly lighter or darker colour than the kit itself.

8/10 :)
 
I tried something a wee different for this celtic kit. Also tried the z12 template. Any rates while I work on throwing together an away kit?

celtickotw_H-1.png
 
Another day, another template. Thoughts? This time showcased with Man United.

manutdx.png

​
 
Mike said:
Another day, another template. Thoughts? This time showcased with Man United.

manutdx.png

​
Click to expand...

Looks really good. Like what you did with the collar and the main design looks really nice. I feel like it would suit Everton very well.
 
jmoser said:
Looks really good. Like what you did with the collar and the main design looks really nice. I feel like it would suit Everton very well.
Click to expand...

Cheers, I'll give it a go.

evertonr.png

​
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

FMBase

Beta

Resources

Back
Top