The 'Rate My Kit' Thread

[Mike]

HSV
Home:

I tried basing this on the new thailand shirt,
but i dunno
something just isn't right with this kit?
thoughts please
​

I'll tell you what isn't right.. you posted this just after StuW's new rule so I can't see it bigger. Absolutely fantastic mate, keep it up.

 

[Joss]

HSV
Home:

I tried basing this on the new thailand shirt,
but i dunno
something just isn't right with this kit?
thoughts please
​

Too much going on maybe? If you have the PSD maybe make the HSV logo a little smaller and/or stick to one colour (white) in the strip on the chest.

Nice idea though!

---------- Post added at 05:41 AM ---------- Previous post was at 05:40 AM ----------

Another one by me. My first attempt at using the FB template. Fairly simple, as im am getting used to the templates still

Simple but nice. Badge is too big, but 7.5/10 =)

 

[iamauser]

Last one from me tonight. Something a little different,

 

[Joss]

Trying some new textures and extras etc.

Which is the better one out of the four? With/Without badges etc.

---------- Post added at 06:02 AM ---------- Previous post was at 06:01 AM ----------

Last one from me tonight. Something a little different,

Very nice I think! How do you blur it like that?

8/10 =)

 

[*Jones*]

Can't really tell the difference in texture?
also, the Milan badge is too small
& where did you get the italy thing from?

 

[Mike]

Joss - the last of the four is the better, obviously if they had that kit in real life with the badges and what not, but I think, as Jones mentioned, the badge is on the small side and it's odd seeing Milan without their traditional stripes. Nonetheless, you are getting better by the kit, so 8/10 for me

 

[Joss]

Can't really tell the difference in texture?
also, the Milan badge is too small
& where did you get the italy thing from?

Think it's just meant to be darker, all designed by Mantralux HERE.

Joss - the last of the four is the better, obviously if they had that kit in real life with the badges and what not, but I think, as Jones mentioned, the badge is on the small side and it's odd seeing Milan without their traditional stripes. Nonetheless, you are getting better by the kit, so 8/10 for me

See what you both mean with the Milan badge, I've got the PSD (s) so will edit it.

Yeah, obviously they traditionally have stripes, but I'm still trying new things, and liked the design so chose this, think it works OK tbh.

 

[*Jones*]

oh, and i've seen you on about the manufacturer logo blurring when re-sizing, you don't need to resize it as it's already a good size

 

[r4v3ncl4w]

Still trying to get used to it again, these are for the local football club

 

[whyelse]

Dont like the way the sponsor is and adidas logo too small

Comment please

---------- Post added at 06:00 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:58 PM ----------

Still trying to get used to it again, these are for the local football club

Good except for i dont like the sponsor could be nice with a colour overlay though

 

[*Jones*]

HSV
H/A

The sponsor needs sorting,
it mucked up when the kit was resized
​

 

[Mike]

Your old HSV > new one like the away, bar the sponsor which you mentioned.

 

[Mr Chelsea]

I have uploaded very similar kits a few pages back, but I've changed them a bit.
What do you think?

 

[*Jones*]

Your old HSV > new one like the away, bar the sponsor which you mentioned.

nah, i prefer these.
so though luck, these are the ones that will be used in the megapack

 

[mrjack41]

I have uploaded very similar kits a few pages back, but I've changed them a bit.
What do you think?

Chelsea badge too big. And on the away and third the badge should be directly underneath the logo. I like the design though. 7/10

 

[toxicflame]

I have uploaded very similar kits a few pages back, but I've changed them a bit.
What do you think?

Like the design of the home and away kits. Not a fan of the colour of the third. Also the sponsors look like they're are floating above the kit, try putting them below the texture layer, and the badges are too big. Apart from that good kits 6/10

 

[Mr Chelsea]

Like the design of the home and away kits. Not a fan of the colour of the third. Also the sponsors look like they're are floating above the kit, try putting them below the texture layer, and the badges are too big. Apart from that good kits 6/10

Chelsea badge too big. And on the away and third the badge should be directly underneath the logo. I like the design though. 7/10

Thank you both for the compliments and criticism. I'll work on them.

 

[mrjack41]

Arsenal home kit i just made; quite happy with it:

 

[r4v3ncl4w]

I have uploaded very similar kits a few pages back, but I've changed them a bit.
What do you think?

I actually like how the sponsor looks,it does feel a bit unrealistic though.

9/10

 

[whyelse]

Here are two kits from my serie a kit pack