The 'Rate My Kit' Thread

[Witalo Carlos Brazil]

Witalo, I have to say, every single one of the kits that you replicate has been done so to a tremendous level of accuracy and realism. I cannot believe how good your kits are, and I think it would be an understatement to say that you are one of the best kit-makers on the site. Very, very well done.

Thanks!
But I have to be very inspired when I do, but do ugly ones like this that just posting of Newcastle!

I have the design as a hobby, and I love Photoshop & CorelDraw!

and you are also VERY good!

 

[jmoser]

Witalo, I have to say, every single one of the kits that you replicate has been done so to a tremendous level of accuracy and realism. I cannot believe how good your kits are, and I think it would be an understatement to say that you are one of the best kit-makers on the site. Very, very well done.

I agree. He's awesome, and he doesn't always get the credit he deserves. Now if only he would start entering kit of the week. His replicas are very well done, but it would be nice to see what he can do on fantasy kits. A little Brazilian flair never hurts a competition...

 

[lynchyyyy]

Can someone please give me some feedback please !!

Aberdeen H|A|T
View attachment 176037View attachment 176036View attachment 176038

Dundee Utd H|A

View attachment 176040View attachment 176039

 

[Witalo Carlos Brazil]

I agree. He's awesome, and he doesn't always get the credit he deserves. Now if only he would start entering kit of the week. His replicas are very well done, but it would be nice to see what he can do on fantasy kits. A little Brazilian flair never hurts a competition...

Can I be good, but not as much as you!

I will make some Fantasy for the next posts!

 

[jmoser]

Can I be good, but not as much as you!

I will make some Fantasy for the next posts!

Sounds good! You should enter Kit of the Week next time.

 

[Calum]

Please rate

FK Borac Banja Luka H-A

 

[pistolped7]

New template, stripes this time (uh oh!). Displayed here with Barca. Thoughts?

​

Awesome as per, but the the only thing I'm not keen on is the white detailing, personally prefer yellow. Still, lovely template. You should make a fantasy template pack!

^^ Well done Chokopop. They look good, did you make that template yourself? It's nice and simple, but effective nonetheless. The away kit is definitely my favorite, I love what you've done with the badge, I think it looks awesome.

Now for my latest work:

Kaizer Chiefs "African Heritage" fantasy kit:

I just made a shirt and thought it looked awesome, but I needed a team logo to slap on it. I know these aren't Kaizer Chiefs' colors (that's about all I know about Kaizer Chiefs), so let's just pretend it is a limited edition "African Heritage" third kit or something. The truth is it was supposed to be a Ghana or Cameroon kit or something, but the Kaizer Chiefs logo looked better, so I stuck with it. And the kit manufacturer is LRG if you were wondering what company that logo was.

That's too frickin' cool. 15/10.

 

[Canesdude]

Witalo, even though those Frankfurt kits are horrible, your replicas certainly aren't! 9/10.




Derby County 11/12 Home

View attachment 175658

Can I get some rates on this?

 

[Harriers09]

Can I get some rates on this?

7/10. nothing wrong with them, they just dont stand out IMO

 

[Canesdude]

7/10. nothing wrong with them, they just dont stand out IMO

How does it not stand out? It's a copy of Derby's kits for next season.

 

[Harriers09]

How does it not stand out? It's a copy of Derby's kits for next season.

well looks like derby's kit for next season wont stand out then. TBH i dont like the template

 

[userfrenzy]

My custom Fiorentina Away Jersey - Rates and constructive criticism appreciated

 

[Canesdude]

well looks like derby's kit for next season wont stand out then. TBH i dont like the template

So because it looks like their kits for next reason it doesn't stand out?

Witalo does the exact same thing but everyone loves his kits.


Userfrenzy, I like everything but the sponsor. 8/10

 

[Harriers09]

My custom Fiorentina Away Jersey - Rates and constructive criticism appreciated

i like the three adidas stripes going across the shirt.

my only criticism would be i dont like the two different purple colours (one for logo etc... one for sleeves), on their own they look good but im not sure they go well together....actually....is the purple for the collar different from the logo colour?

in all i like the kit and the idea, just not sure the colours go together that well IMO

hope this helps a lil

---------- Post added at 12:07 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:06 AM ----------

So because it looks like their kits for next reason it doesn't stand out?

Witalo does the exact same thing but everyone loves his kits.


Userfrenzy, I like everything but the sponsor. 8/10

ok i wont rate yours any more...sorry

 

[jmoser]

That's too frickin' cool. 15/10.

Aww thanks mate, I thought it was pretty awesome too.

And when are you going to start making kits again? I miss them.

 

[I7IDanny]

Manchester United Kits, made to request:

View attachment 176031View attachment 176032View attachment 176030


Napoli Kits, made to request:
View attachment 176034View attachment 176035View attachment 176033

Any rates on these? Would be nice to get feedback

 

[Witalo Carlos Brazil]

Brazil National Team Home & Away
View attachment 176101View attachment 176100

 

[Witalo Carlos Brazil]

View attachment 176103View attachment 176102

My Vasco da Gama Home & Away (anything done in a hurry ends well ...)

 

[Malarkey]

View attachment 176103View attachment 176102

My Vasco da Gama Home & Away (anything done in a hurry ends well ...)

7/10 for both, i dont like the bit in the top left

 

[pistolped7]

Aww thanks mate, I thought it was pretty awesome too.

And when are you going to start making kits again? I miss them.

As soon as I get PS back again. Sucks not doin 'em.