The 'Rate My Kit' Thread

[StuW]

Chile Copa America H/A -

AC Milan Away -

---------- Post added at 01:44 AM ---------- Previous post was at 01:19 AM ----------

Marseille H/A, in my own kit make, 8eight -

 

[toxicflame]

10/10 for both those Chile tops absolutely love them.
9/10 for the Milan.
6/10 for the Marsielle Home and 8/10 for the away, mainly because I don't like the sponsors.

 

[jmoser]

I made a new kit style and I was wondering what you guys thought of it. Here it is as a Spurs kit. This is my first time ever doing my own kit texture so if you spot anything that looks wrong, feel free to let me know. It is still very much a work in progress, so I am definitely open to any suggestions to improve the texture or shape. It is supposed to have kind of a fitted look to it like the new Adidas kits.

Spoiler

 

[peskybendben]

That is superb. I love it! Good work.

 

[jojcik]

Everton FC H/A

 

[peskybendben]

Sponsors are too low, and badges are a bit small, but otherwise nice kits. 7/10

 

[Sid]

Shakhtysor H/A/T

Tried something new on the third and the mitre logo on the third should be black but i didn't save the psd.

 

[peskybendben]

Not too fond of the multi-coloured sleeves on the third, black would look better in my opinion. Can't fault the home and away, apart from perhaps the collar should be black on the home maybe... Rates are 8/10, 9/10, 6/10.

 

[Sid]

Not too fond of the multi-coloured sleeves on the third, black would look better in my opinion. Can't fault the home and away, apart from perhaps the collar should be black on the home maybe... Rates are 8/10, 9/10, 6/10.

yeah, i normally do weird designs if i make a third and i've never properly used the multicolour on kits before

 

[Pessh]

I made a new kit style and I was wondering what you guys thought of it. Here it is as a Spurs kit. This is my first time ever doing my own kit texture so if you spot anything that looks wrong, feel free to let me know. It is still very much a work in progress, so I am definitely open to any suggestions to improve the texture or shape. It is supposed to have kind of a fitted look to it like the new Adidas kits.

Spoiler

I understand you're going for a fitted look but it comes in a bit too much above the hips in my opinion, looks like a women's shirt. Sleeves seem a bit off too, not sure if its the proportions or just the angle but definitely needs some work. Other than that though looks very promising.

 

[Sid]

I agree, comes in a little bit too much, just like a milimetre and also the side of the sleeves that is closest to the shirt could maybe be a bit closer to the shirt so that it nearly touches it.


does that make sense?

 

[jmoser]

I agree, comes in a little bit too much, just like a milimetre and also the side of the sleeves that is closest to the shirt could maybe be a bit closer to the shirt so that it nearly touches it.


does that make sense?

Yeah the shape of the main body of the kit was something that I was definitely thinking about doing some more work on. Your probably right about it being a bit narrow in the middle there. And what you said about the sleeves makes perfect sense. This is just the first go around, so it will definitely be changing a bit in the future.

 

[Sid]

Yeah the shape of the main body of the kit was something that I was definitely thinking about doing some more work on. Your probably right about it being a bit narrow in the middle there. And what you said about the sleeves makes perfect sense. This is just the first go around, so it will definitely be changing a bit in the future.

Looks very promising

 

[jmoser]

cheers, I look forward to refining it and seeing what i can come up with

 

[prow07]

Haven't put any kits in here for a while...

Barca

The Japanese Team for this weeks KotW

Some Lyon kits that i didn't enter to KotW last week...

And the ones that i did enter...

 

[Sid]

Haven't put any kits in here for a while...

Barca

The Japanese Team for this weeks KotW

Some Lyon kits that i didn't enter to KotW last week...

And the ones that i did enter...

Barca: 9/10 Very well executed, don't like the template enough to give a 10.
Japanese Team: 8 for the home, very nice but the gold stripe next to the black bit on the left should also be on the right or not there at all otherwise it looks out of place. 9 for the away, really nice, don't normally like pinstripes.
Lyon: 8 for the Home, don't like the sponsor but very nice apart from that, 9 for the Away, love it, but again, the sponsor loses it a mark.
Lyon 2: 9.5 for the Home, don't like the template, 9.5 for the Away, love it.

Great kits

 

[peskybendben]

Barcelona kit is my favourite from that bunch. The template caught my eye as soon as I saw it. Good job, 10/10.

 

[jmoser]

Version 2 of my template. Focused on the shape for this update, will get around to the texture eventually.

 

[Sid]

Version 2 of my template. Focused on the shape for this update, will get around to the texture eventually.

Much better, looks awesome :wub:

 

[I Like Pie]

This is my first attempt at making a kit Wanna see if people think its any good.