The 'Rate My Kit' Thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Jake
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 4K
  • Views Views 1M
Status
Not open for further replies.
Calum said:
city..

rates?
Click to expand...

No offence, I really don't like them

The sleeve badges are terrible, although this could be SSD's fault. Not yours!!

On the inside of the kits, recolouring the inside just doesn't work IMO.

5/10
 
pistolped7 said:
5/10 for me.

Sponsor's a bit big, collars wrong colour at the back I think, don't like the badges or the wee line at the bottom.
Click to expand...
bit harsh, for a second attempt they are great! 8/10, my only problem is the crest is too low, i think you should remove the line going across at the top, and move the badges up :) IMO
 
Malarkey said:
bit harsh, for a second attempt they are great! 8/10, my only problem is the crest is too low, i think you should remove the line going across at the top, and move the badges up :) IMO
Click to expand...

Not harsh, just being honest. I know they're only a second attempt, but I'm giving him my honest opinion. I'm sure he wouldn't want me giving him 10/10 if I don't think they are 10/10. :S
 
I am new to kit making but here are some new AS Monaco kits I made for a save I am doing. Any opinions?


Home
Monaco_H.png
Away
Monaco_A.png
Third
Monaco_T.png


not sure about the third, but needed something to wear against red and white stripes
 
jmoser said:
I am new to kit making but here are some new AS Monaco kits I made for a save I am doing. Any opinions?


Home
Monaco_H.png
Away
Monaco_A.png
Third
Monaco_T.png


not sure about the third, but needed something to wear against red and white stripes
Click to expand...

Wow, they're really good! 10/10, really struggling to find anything wrong with them!
 
jmoser said:
I am new to kit making but here are some new AS Monaco kits I made for a save I am doing. Any opinions?


Home
Monaco_H.png
Away
Monaco_A.png
Third
Monaco_T.png


not sure about the third, but needed something to wear against red and white stripes
Click to expand...

wow... these are fantastic :) 10/10 from me
 
jmoser said:
I am new to kit making but here are some new AS Monaco kits I made for a save I am doing. Any opinions?


Home
Monaco_H.png
Away
Monaco_A.png
Third
Monaco_T.png


not sure about the third, but needed something to wear against red and white stripes
Click to expand...
you are new to kit making? ;) im gonna join everyone else by putting 10/10 for all of them...flawless :)
 
jmoser said:
I am new to kit making but here are some new AS Monaco kits I made for a save I am doing. Any opinions?


Home
Monaco_H.png
Away
Monaco_A.png
Third
Monaco_T.png


not sure about the third, but needed something to wear against red and white stripes
Click to expand...

9/10 for me. Not 10/10 because I don't like the stoke effect you've put on the sponsors. :)
 
jmoser said:
I am new to kit making but here are some new AS Monaco kits I made for a save I am doing. Any opinions?


Home
Monaco_H.png
Away
Monaco_A.png
Third
Monaco_T.png


not sure about the third, but needed something to wear against red and white stripes
Click to expand...

love them 10/10
 
Malarkey said:
bit harsh, for a second attempt they are great! 8/10, my only problem is the crest is too low, i think you should remove the line going across at the top, and move the badges up :) IMO
Click to expand...

pistolped7 said:
5/10 for me.

Sponsor's a bit big, collars wrong colour at the back I think, don't like the badges or the wee line at the bottom.
Click to expand...

Thanks guys i'll take your feedback on board
 
Well thanks for the compliments and criticisms guys :D. I'll agree with Ed Syers that the sponsors still aren't quite right, I was struggling a little bit to get them how I wanted. I am still exploring all the features of photoshop.
 
Thought I would try something a little different. Any thoughts?

lazio-1.png
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

FMBase

Beta

Resources

Back
Top