The 'Rate my Photoshop work' Thread

[toddzy]

View attachment 111898
​

Slight edit, not sure if it works or not?

 

[Nathan]

View attachment 111898
​

Slight edit, not sure if it works or not?

Definately better without the change.

 

[Calum]

View attachment 111898​

Slight edit, not sure if it works or not?

hate the team

love the sig

 

[fuelledbypassion]

View attachment 111898​

Slight edit, not sure if it works or not?

I prefer it with the change :O

 

[TheMjt]

Possible comp entry, don't like the stroke tbh, might make a grey one

---------- Post added at 02:17 AM ---------- Previous post was at 02:04 AM ----------

Prefer this one

 

[toddzy]

Meh, not much else I can say. It appears pretty basic.

 

[Nathan]

Mjt, those are way bigger than 500x150 which is the maximum size for the competition. Also make the render so it can actually be seen properly, very basic sig.

 

[AussieOchoa]

Just a little free time

View attachment 111927​

Really happy with it, but it can definately be improved :S

 

[toddzy]

Works really well mate, I really I like it. 8/10 from me!

 

[toddzy]

Ronaldinho Sig ;

View attachment 111971​

 

[goonergun435]

Ronaldinho Sig ;

View attachment 111971​

10/10 U R Not Falling Behind

 

[Nathan]

10/10 U R Not Falling Behind

Calm down.

 

[goonergun435]

Calm down.

sorry i have gone a bit over the top

 

[*Jones*]

Ronaldinho Sig ;

View attachment 111971​

not 10 out of 10 i'm afraid,
blending of the sig is pretty good, but the background doesn't really work and then the text doesn't fit in either... :/

 

[belz]

Last thing I 'designed' was a lot of months ago, in one of the first SOTW, some may remember that Luisão sig. Well I'm not really happy with this outcome, but as I never touched PS again, decided to start off a beginner. I never worked with renders, only with full stocks, so wasn't used to this.

Again, not pleased with the outcome, but darn happy to get back to photoshop.8-|

 

[fuelledbypassion]

not 10 out of 10 i'm afraid,
blending of the sig is pretty good, but the background doesn't really work and then the text doesn't fit in either... :/

I disagree, I think the writing is good, great sig imo

 

[toddzy]

not 10 out of 10 i'm afraid,
blending of the sig is pretty good, but the background doesn't really work and then the text doesn't fit in either... :/

I disagree, I think the writing is good, great sig imo

I actually agree with Jones tbh. Thanks for for the compliment though mate. :wub:

Heres the original BG, I just edited the Salturation on it.



---------- Post added at 02:49 AM ---------- Previous post was at 01:59 AM ----------

Possible entry? Thoughts?​

 

[Nathan]

I actually agree with Jones tbh. Thanks for for the compliment though mate. :wub:

Heres the original BG, I just edited the Salturation on it.



---------- Post added at 02:49 AM ---------- Previous post was at 01:59 AM ----------

Possible entry? Thoughts?​

Much better than your previous, should seriously think about entering that one.

 

[toddzy]

Ive edited it and rubbed away the parts that overlap his shoulders, would that be better?

 

[Nathan]

Ive edited it and rubbed away the parts that overlap his shoulders, would that be better?

Whatever you think looks best.