The World's Top 50

  • Thread starter Thread starter Tom_7
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 79
  • Views Views 6K
Where's Forlan? Dani Alves shouldn't really be that high.
As for Adebayor... strike him off- his jobs a striker... yet he couldn't hit water if he fell out of a boat!

Why does everyone keep mentioning Forlan, In my opinion he isnt that good, how long did it take for him to score for Man Utd?
 
why is phil neville not on the list, also titus bramble is number 1 defender in the world,

forlan is ****
 
Carragher is not in the top 50 In my opinion. Mascherano is just a tough tackler with little skill and reina makes too many mistakes

Okay this may be me just being a bias Liverpool fan, but how could you say that about 3 of the premier leagues top players.. I mean look at 36 - 50 they are not the best players in the world. It looks like for the last 15 or so you've just looked at all the best clubs in the world and chosen their 2nd or 3rd best of each position..

Also is this based on FM or real life?
 
Forlan, on current form, is arguably one of the best strikers in the world atm!
Your point about him scoring for Utd isn't really relevant to him being one of the world's best players currently, really. He wasn't great in the Prem, I totally agree... But then again, look at Shevchenko, Veron, etc... All of whom had massive worldwide reputations before coming to the Premier League, it's a tough league...
So maybe some of the Prem-based players should be higher... but Forlan is definately NOT ****
 
hang on, you say veron but wot has happen to him since leave the prem, nothing, and sheva couldnt handle the itailan league last year so he cant blame the prem. forlan only scores against sub standard defences it is like saying tht the top scorer in wales is the best player in the world as he scores against **** defenders
 
yeh but y have him whn u can have forlan in the list
 
Okay this may be me just being a bias Liverpool fan, but how could you say that about 3 of the premier leagues top players.. I mean look at 36 - 50 they are not the best players in the world. It looks like for the last 15 or so you've just looked at all the best clubs in the world and chosen their 2nd or 3rd best of each position..

Also is this based on FM or real life?

It is based on real life. You do not know what you are talking about if you think carragher is in the top 50 in the world mate. Cambiasso, Yaya Toure, Arshavin, Sneijder etc all world class players. I bet you would happily have any of them in Liverpool. Anyway its my opinion, you don't have to agree with me
 
carragher is ****, ****** **** why do people rate him sorry, srktel is better then him, hypia was better then him, he wouldnt make the list for any normal bloke, you liverpool fans just think he is good for 1 gud season.
 
Forlan, on current form, is arguably one of the best strikers in the world atm!
Your point about him scoring for Utd isn't really relevant to him being one of the world's best players currently, really. He wasn't great in the Prem, I totally agree... But then again, look at Shevchenko, Veron, etc... All of whom had massive worldwide reputations before coming to the Premier League, it's a tough league...
So maybe some of the Prem-based players should be higher... but Forlan is definately NOT ****

Shevchenko and Veron are passed it and both struggled after leaving England. As for Forlan, I did say this list was on ability not form and in my opinion you cannot even mention him in the same breath as Totti, Del Piero or Raul. Forlan is not ****, but in the top 50 in the world, i don't think so mate

---------- Post added at 09:09 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:06 PM ----------

carragher is ****, ****** **** why do people rate him sorry, srktel is better then him, hypia was better then him, he wouldnt make the list for any normal bloke, you liverpool fans just think he is good for 1 gud season.

Good point mate, Skrtel and Agger are both better. Why do people say he is good?, he is slow, weak, not a great header of the ball. All he is good at is tackling and that aint anything special
 
I said Veron, but I said before coming to the Premier League, did I not??
Same goes for Shevchenko.
Wait a minute... Forlan scored 35 goals last season, winning his 2nd European Golden Boot. Now surely all of those 35 goals weren't against 'sub-standard' defences were they? I remember that he scored 2 against Barca and another against Real, they're not what I'd called 'sub-standard'!
 
So it's "your opinion" I understand that so if you can't handle critism from OTHER PEOPLE'S opinions, why upload it? Maybe you should have just printed it off, stuck it on your wall and been very proud of this... "Acomplishment"? of naming 50 footballers.
 
I said Veron, but I said before coming to the Premier League, did I not??
Same goes for Shevchenko.
Wait a minute... Forlan scored 35 goals last season, winning his 2nd European Golden Boot. Now surely all of those 35 goals weren't against 'sub-standard' defences were they? I remember that he scored 2 against Barca and another against Real, they're not what I'd called 'sub-standard'!

Yes but that was 1 season. Raul has done it for a number of seasons. If Sir Alex doesn't rate someone, lets face it, he aint going to be good. He is only a few years younger than Raul and hasn't one a quarter of the trophies Raul has!!
 
I am a liverpool fan and i dont think carragher is that good
 
carragher is ****, ****** **** why do people rate him sorry, srktel is better then him, hypia was better then him, he wouldnt make the list for any normal bloke, you liverpool fans just think he is good for 1 gud season.

What the actual ****.. You can call Carragher **** yet Vidic is 13th! I mean who puts Vidic 13th in a list of 50 best players. I never said Carragher was amazing, but how can you put Vidic there yet no Skrtel, Agger or even Ferdinand?
 
Yes but that was 1 season. Raul has done it for a number of seasons. If Sir Alex doesn't rate someone, lets face it, he aint going to be good. He is only a few years younger than Raul and hasn't one a quarter of the trophies Raul has!!

Other than Utd he hasn't really played for a potential trophy winning team though has he really.
And it isn't just 1 season... over the past 5 years he's scored 117 goals!
I can think of only Eto'o maybe who's scored more!
Raul, on the other hand has scored 79.
Forlan isn't top 50 ability-wise??
Are you sure?
 
So it's "your opinion" I understand that so if you can't handle critism from OTHER PEOPLE'S opinions, why upload it? Maybe you should have just printed it off, stuck it on your wall and been very proud of this... "Acomplishment"? of naming 50 footballers.

Very funny mate. I can accept other people's opinions. It is hardly critism, it is just a debate. I just think that anyone who says Carragher is in the best 50 players in the world. I didn't say it was an accomplishment did I?? No, I just wanted to view what people thought, I didn't think i would get abuse from a LIVERPOOL supporter, who thinks Carragher is good??? If you can't face losing the title to a better team, there is no need to take it out on me
 
I said Veron, but I said before coming to the Premier League, did I not??
Same goes for Shevchenko.
Wait a minute... Forlan scored 35 goals last season, winning his 2nd European Golden Boot. Now surely all of those 35 goals weren't against 'sub-standard' defences were they? I remember that he scored 2 against Barca and another against Real, they're not what I'd called 'sub-standard'!

This fits in nicely also. To the person who said "Wales's top scored should be the best player in the world blah blah blah" Well he only scored 34 goals.. So no.. He's the 2nd best player in the world.. Behind Forlan!!! LOOL! Although I'd rather have the Welsh guy than Aderbayor.. I mean give Wenger another choice and he would say no way to signing that ****.

---------- Post added at 10:27 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:19 PM ----------

He is good.. I mean he would be England's 3rd choice CB.. Why are you all hating on him so much? And my point still stands for Mascherano and Alonso. If they are not in the top 50? Then how come Real Madrid and Barca are trying there best to sign them?.. I'm pretty sure if in 6 months time they are playing in Spain they will be in this list.. Yet because they are Liverpool players they wouldn't be.
 
Back
Top