Top Ten Managers of the World Cup

*Jones*

Pikachuuuuuuuu
Dec 28, 2009
2,350
0
0
If a mod see's this thread as being pointless, then so be it;
i just thought it'd make a change from the usual stuff;
albeit if it is a tad late....


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Sometimes in-depth tactical analysis can overcomplicate the fairly basic job of a manager – to get the best out of his players. Here are the ten managers who did that well at this World Cup.

10. Takeshi Okada, Japan
The allegation before the tournament was that Okada was failing to get the best out of a decent bunch of players, but a late switch in tactics meant Japan were reasonably impressive in their advance to the second round. The surprise use of Keshuke Honda upfront was inspired, and Honda received plenty of support from four midfield runners in a formation that was rigid defensively and fluid upfront. The second round game against Paraguay was awful, but it was the first time Japan had got to that stage on foreign soil.

9. Carlos Alberto Parreira, South Africa
South Africa were written off before the tournament as no-hopers, but Parreira’s job in a relatively short space of time should be respected; when he took over last October, they’d lost their last five games. Under his reign, they were unbeaten in 13 coming into the tournament. They led against Mexico, only capitulated in the final minutes against Uruguay when down to ten men, and they recorded a memorable, if futile, victory over France in the final group game. Not qualifying was regarded as a failure in South Africa, but Parreira did well to even give them a chance.

8. Gerardo Martino, Paraguay
What will you remember about Paraguay’s World Cup in six months’ time? Probably very little, but Paraguayans will remember it forever – the first time in their history they had reached the quarter-final stage. And when they got there, they gave Spain a fright – only going behind the final ten minutes, having missed a penalty. Their 4-4-2 / 4-3-3 hybrid was reasonably interesting, and one bizarre point of note was Martino’s decision to change six players between the second round and the quarter-final – surely a World Cup knockout stages record.

7. Ricki Herbert, New Zealand


Ricki Herbert

7th place for the manager of a team who didn’t qualify for the knockout stages seems ridiculous, but Herbert’s side were the only unbeaten team in the competition. On paper, his squad was the weakest of the 32 teams, and they had the longest odds to win the competition. Herbert’s 3-4-3 system made New Zealand difficult to break down, and levelled the playing field against technically superior opponents. The draw with the reigning World Champions was a genuine achievement – Herbert’s tactics guiding players from the likes of Plymouth Argyle and Motherwell to a point against players from Juventus, Milan and Roma.

6. Bert van Marwijk, Holland
His biggest achievement, of course, was to keep the in-fighting to a minimum. But tactically van Marwijk managed to create a well-organised, functional XI. They defended well from the front, vital since their back four was supposedly their weak link, but often failed to convince going forward. Ultimately, they’ll be remembered for the spoiling tactics they used in the final.

5. Joachim Loew, Germany
It was quite a task for Loew to create a cohesive team. Michael Ballack, the captain, was injured shortly before the tournament, whilst Lukas Podolski and Miroslov Klose were coming off awful domestic seasons, and Mesut Oezil, Sami Khedira and Thomas Mueller were highly-rated but unproven at international level. But Loew’s side worked brilliantly together, producing three of the most impressive displays of the tournament against Australia, England and Argentina. He managed to maintain the positive German stereotypes (ruthless, efficient, well-organised) whilst ditching the negative ones (boring, lacking flair) to create a terrific side that hit greater peaks than any other.

4. Vicente del Bosque, Spain
As the winner of the World Cup, he should probably be number one. But del Bosque was in charge of the most talented squad in the competition, so would have had to do something spectacular to be deemed as furthering the abilities of his players. Spectacular? Probably not, but ruthless and efficient. He never really seemed sure of his best XI – first Spain lost, then Torres struggled for four games, then Villa wasn’t at his best for the final two. Not that it mattered. The use of two holding midfielders worked wonders when it came to ball retention, and not conceding a goal in four knockout games is an incredible record.



Marcelo Bielsa

3. Marcelo Bielsa, Chile
We all knew Chile were a major force after their highly successful qualification campaign, but that shouldn’t detract from the fact that Bielsa was getting the best out of a set of relative unknowns. The first two games against Honduras and Switzerland should have been won by more convincing scorelines than 1-0, and a fully fit Humberto Suazo would have made a huge difference. Chile were unfortunate to come up against the two pre-tournament favourites after that – had they been given the draw of their South American neighbour Uruguay or Paraguay, they surely would have fared better.

2. Oscar Tabarez, Uruguay
Tabarez is a true tactician. He didn’t come into the tournament with a favoured system or a stubborn belief in how his team should set out, he altered his formation and approach according to the opposition he faced. There is a case for saying Uruguay played five separate formations in their seven games – the only constant was the use of two holding midfielders to protect the defence, and they didn’t concede a single goal in the group stage. His tactics in the 1-0 win over Mexico were particularly inspired.

1. Milovan Rajevac, Ghana
Let’s remember, very few Ghanaian players other than Michael Essien were well-known at the start of 2010. And who had heard of their manager? Rajevac’s previous coaching experience consisted of coaching the likes of FK Vojvodina, Borac Cacak and Zeleznik. He created an excellent, disciplined young side that impressed at the Africa Cup of Nations, keeping the same formation and strategy for the World Cup, where they had to do without Essien. The 4-1-4-1 was solid at the back, dominant in midfield, and Asamoah Gyan was a constant threat upfront. Were it not for Luis Suarez’s hand, Rajevac would have been the first ever manager to guide an African side to the semi-finals of a World Cup – and this from a side who were favourites to finish bottom of their group.

Edit:
A Twitter survey of ZM’s followers resulted in the view that the top 8 should be Loew, Tabarez, Bielsa, del Bosque, van Marwijk, Rejavac, Herbert, Martino, in that order.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

http://www.zonalmarking.net/2010/07/20/world-cup-2010-top-ten-managers/

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -


do people agree with that?
- if so, why?
- if not, why?

i personally think that Loew should be higher up than 5th becuase he got an unknown; un-tested German side to the semi-final where they were beaten by Spain,

I think everyone would've rather had a Germany - Spain final but it wasn't to be.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

JDY

Member
Dec 7, 2008
3,533
0
36
I agree with most of it. I would swap the top 2 around although both did fantastic jobs.
 

Mike.

Moderator
Staff member
Feb 15, 2009
31,891
31
48
bielsa :wub: lit up the wworld cup for me with his unique style, it worked much better than when he tried it with argentina and Rajevac has done so well with ghana, and they can only get better
 

Carine

Member
Apr 17, 2010
1,029
0
0
Ricki Herbert did an excellent job imo -- probably the best as his team were (sorry, should have been) dire. There were amateurs in that team and they played with more professionalism than France, England and Italy (supposed power-houses of international football.)

Loew also did an excellent job, but I don't completely buy-in to Germany's squad being a collection of unknown and untested players. I'd heard of every single member of their squad before the tournament kicked-off and most of them (if not all? correct me if I'm wrong) have experience on the big stage (Euro club football.) It was still a fine achievement though, as they weren't pre-tournament favourites.

Ghana's manager would be my second pick -- if it weren't for one missed penalty, they were in the Semis.
 

Kylo

MAAAATTT DAMMOONNNNNN
Oct 22, 2009
1,757
0
0
Isn't Capello statistically the best England manager for a long time? Mainly qualifying, but still.

Maradona and Him should be on the list, mainly Maradona because he's so funny :D
 

Mike.

Moderator
Staff member
Feb 15, 2009
31,891
31
48
Ricki Herbert did an excellent job imo -- probably the best as his team were (sorry, should have been) dire. There were amateurs in that team and they played with more professionalism than France, England and Italy (supposed power-houses of international football.)

Loew also did an excellent job, but I don't completely buy-in to Germany's squad being a collection of unknown and untested players. I'd heard of every single member of their squad before the tournament kicked-off and most of them (if not all? correct me if I'm wrong) have experience on the big stage (Euro club football.) It was still a fine achievement though, as they weren't pre-tournament favourites.

Ghana's manager would be my second pick -- if it weren't for one missed penalty, they were in the Semis.
agree about loew in terms of the world cup. but in terms of the impact they have on their national football he'd be top because of the work he and klinsmann have done for germany in the last 6 years
 

Dunc

Keyboard Warrior
Dec 3, 2009
10,699
0
36
Seems a good list. Can't think of anyone I would change on it.
 

Carine

Member
Apr 17, 2010
1,029
0
0
agree about loew in terms of the world cup. but in terms of the impact they have on their national football he'd be top because of the work he and klinsmann have done for germany in the last 6 years
Yes, I agree about his previous work and I'm a huge fan, but in terms of the WC only I think others would pip him to the post. Then again, do you (as in the voters) dismiss his collective works, which have led to the recent performances? It's a tricky one, lol.
 

MCR_17

Member
Aug 7, 2010
117
0
0
2. Oscar Tabarez, Uruguay
Tabarez is a true tactician. He didn’t come into the tournament with a favoured system or a stubborn belief in how his team should set out, he altered his formation and approach according to the opposition he faced. There is a case for saying Uruguay played five separate formations in their seven games – the only constant was the use of two holding midfielders to protect the defence, and they didn’t concede a single goal in the group stage. His tactics in the 1-0 win over Mexico were particularly inspired.​



+1

I'm from Uruguay.
 

5ICK

Member
May 16, 2010
539
0
0
I think that this list is correct.

Maybe USA Manager to be included, as you say. Or to be number 11.
 

aliciawitt

Member
Aug 11, 2010
17
0
0
35
Managers don't always receive as much attention as their players but that doesn't make them any less important. From selection to tactics to substitutions, managers have to take risks and have the final say in make or break decisions.
 
Top