I've not played this one much myself, but my utd team in the second season is stupidly strong. First season won all cups but lost the league to Liverpool by 1 point (they got 96, i had 95) - 2nd season with this team was a clean sweep, finished on 98 points. I found I was defensively strong but would sometimes struggle to score, Mbappe bailed me out quite often, I was waiting for the new patch to remake my formation but i'm going to go back to LL management and build up, try to get a 4-2-3-1 going.
GK - DDG
CB - Dias
CB - Skriniar
CB - Marquinhos
LWB - Grimaldo
RWB - Kimmich (one of my fave players, I thought his lack of pace would be a problem but he's been solid for me
CM - Savic
CM - Pogba
CM - Fernandes
CF - Mbappe
CF - Martinez
Subs
Olmo
Zaniolo
Upamecano
Haaland
Wan-Bissaka
Tonali
Telles
Fruchtl
Dalot
As you can see, nothing really special, all fairly well known and common players.
Olmo and Zaniolo performed great for me. Wan Bissaka was trash, cost me a fair few points doing stupid things under no pressure.
Pogba was often injured, scored some important goals he's not a player I would buy, I don't understand how he's rated so highly on this. I know this isnt exactly what you were looking for but I think that team would be fairly close. I'd make the following changes:
GK - Alisson
RB - TAA
CM - Havertz
Wingers - Bailey / Dembele / Sane