Underrated, Overrated

[FM Lect]

Who are the most underrated or overrated players on the new update? What do you think? Simple

 

[tommyd150]

andy johnson is over rated... pace 16 acc 16 comp 15 finish 16? cnt hit a barn door in the game haha

 

[forza-juve]

De Rossi looks reasonably under-rated in my opinion. Okay Roma haven't been all that great (might be biased coming from a Juve fan) but De Rossi has looked better than he has done in a couple of years, yet for some reason he's actually been downgraded in the latest update.

Gary Cahill got a bit of a stat increase too, which seems undeserved and is probably only because he moved to Chelsea. Seems like they might've upgraded some Real Madrid players a little too much as well.

 

[Bro]

Burak Yilmaz from Trabzonspor is underrated.

 

[Munroe]

Fellaini is still ridiculously over-rated.

 

[Mike.]

De Rossi looks reasonably under-rated in my opinion. Okay Roma haven't been all that great (might be biased coming from a Juve fan) but De Rossi has looked better than he has done in a couple of years, yet for some reason he's actually been downgraded in the latest update.

Gary Cahill got a bit of a stat increase too, which seems undeserved and is probably only because he moved to Chelsea. Seems like they might've upgraded some Real Madrid players a little too much as well.

cahill hasnt had an upgrade.

 

[eire59]

leigh griffiths is overrated

 

[tommyd150]

fellanis 1 of top 5 or 6 best dm in prem!

 

[Mikon]

Overrated:
Szczesny - who is he to have such ridiculous stats?
Aaron Ramsey - again, who is he to have such high stats?
Wilshere - are you kidding me? He's stats are outrageous! He's A LOT better than Cleverley and Pobga, players that are already making good names for themselves!
Torres - seriously?! His stats are probably the best among all the strikers! In real life he's just...normal...
Cavani - a player that I seriously admire in real life... I just feel he's a bit too good in the game.
Willian(Shakhtar) - I know the player since he's 17 or 18... he is truly good, but I dont think he's that machine... at least for now...
Carrick - I'm a Man Utd fan... but the guy is nothing like that...
Silva, Balotelli, Yaya Touré, Nasri, De Jong - I truly like this players a lot and, in fact, used to buy all of them in previous versions of fm, but just because they're playing for man City it does not necessaraly mean they just became machines...!
Pastore - he might be the best amc in the future... but for now, in the game, he's almost the best in his position... not real.

Underrated:
Neymar - he's going to be the next big thing in Brazil and, in fact, he's way more consistent than the game suggests... actually, he plays 90% of the games well.
Aguero - he's way more consistent in real life than in the game. All his stats are good, but consistency sucks (in the game)
Rogerio Ceni and a lot of brazilian players - to say the least, the game is too much biased on european leagues. Basically the brazilian league sucks big time in comparison to other leagues around the world.
Kaká - again, his consistency sucks in the game...he's a lot more of a performer(in real life) than underperformer...

 

[forza-juve]

cahill hasnt had an upgrade.

Really?!

I was sure his stats were higher... Then again I only did a quick check so I could well be wrong.

 

[FM Lect]

The thing about the brazilian players is true. If Brazil wasnt on the other side of the world it would be rated alot more.

 

[Mike.]

Overrated:
Szczesny - who is he to have such ridiculous stats?
Aaron Ramsey - again, who is he to have such high stats?
Wilshere - are you kidding me? He's stats are outrageous! He's A LOT better than Cleverley and Pobga, players that are already making good names for themselves!
Torres - seriously?! His stats are probably the best among all the strikers! In real life he's just...normal...
Cavani - a player that I seriously admire in real life... I just feel he's a bit too good in the game.
Willian(Shakhtar) - I know the player since he's 17 or 18... he is truly good, but I dont think he's that machine... at least for now...
Carrick - I'm a Man Utd fan... but the guy is nothing like that...
Silva, Balotelli, Yaya Touré, Nasri, De Jong - I truly like this players a lot and, in fact, used to buy all of them in previous versions of fm, but just because they're playing for man City it does not necessaraly mean they just became machines...!
Pastore - he might be the best amc in the future... but for now, in the game, he's almost the best in his position... not real.

Underrated:
Neymar - he's going to be the next big thing in Brazil and, in fact, he's way more consistent than the game suggests... actually, he plays 90% of the games well.
Aguero - he's way more consistent in real life than in the game. All his stats are good, but consistency sucks (in the game)
Rogerio Ceni and a lot of brazilian players - to say the least, the game is too much biased on european leagues. Basically the brazilian league sucks big time in comparison to other leagues around the world.
Kaká - again, his consistency sucks in the game...he's a lot more of a performer(in real life) than underperformer...

Brazil has its own researchers, so that argument doesnt work about being slanted to europe.

Most of the players you mentioned arent particularly over or under-rated. For you dont rate Carrick, despite him being our most consistent mid.
At the end of the day its largely opinion.

And this its very subjective. If people dont like them, there is always the editor.

 

[Mike.]

Really?!

I was sure his stats were higher... Then again I only did a quick check so I could well be wrong.

He's been balanced out, but looks he's had a slight fall, you'd be surprised at what his CA is.

 

[Tyton]

Torres - seriously?! His stats are probably the best among all the strikers! In real life he's just...normal...

WTF am i reading. Go watch his random You Tube Liverpool compilation.

 

[Mikon]

WTF am i reading. Go watch his random You Tube Liverpool compilation.

March and he scored 4 goals?
Making a "best plays" for a dvd is a lot easier than actually playing to worth, I don't know... 30 million pounds?
In real life he's just good, not the best striker in the world.

 

[Mikon]

Brazil has its own researchers, so that argument doesnt work about being slanted to europe.

Most of the players you mentioned arent particularly over or under-rated. For you dont rate Carrick, despite him being our most consistent mid.
At the end of the day its largely opinion.

And this its very subjective. If people dont like them, there is always the editor.

So good and consistent that we had to bring Paul Scholes back from retirement.
In a way it was good, but on the other hand... Carrick is clearly not a player to hold the midfiled on his own.
Ok, he's not overrated.

 

[Mike.]

So good and consistent that we had to bring Paul Scholes back from retirement.
In a way it was good, but on the other hand... Carrick is clearly not a player to hold the midfiled on his own.
Ok, he's not overrated.

You do realise he is a completely different player to scholes, if anything they complement each other. Which still has no bearing on how he is rated in game. He is rated on his own merits, based on performances and stats.

 

[Mikon]

You do realise he is a completely different player to scholes, if anything they complement each other. Which still has no bearing on how he is rated in game. He is rated on his own merits, based on performances and stats.

Scholes changed a lot in the past few years. I do think they play in almost the same position doing almost the same thing.
Younger Scholes was more of an offensive MC, having Keane in a more defensive position.
Now he's more a thinker, a deep lying playmaker just like Carrick. But, I agree with you, Carrick in the game is just like that in real life. Not over or underrated.

 

[tommyd150]

Im a United fan people moan bout carrick? hes been class this season his passing is class he can defend 2 but torres socres like 40goals a season fm? hes fuckinnn wank **** his liverpool days no1 cares hes **** now! and will be **** till he retires 16 and 18pace? idiots!!

 

[puzzled]

Im a United fan people moan bout carrick? hes been class this season his passing is class he can defend 2 but torres socres like 40goals a season fm? hes fuckinnn wank **** his liverpool days no1 cares hes **** now! and will be **** till he retires 16 and 18pace? idiots!!

I get what your saying but Torres is a world class player, he may not being having the best time at Chelsea but he still is a world class players when he's playing at his best.