Well yeh it will be to you as you are and man utd fan but i mean if you watched italian football often you might not think that but as i do watch italian football i no vidic is better then him but ist not obv
it depends on what type of centre back your looking for. Vidic is probably more consistent from what reports i have heard but Chiellini is quite versatile and quick. I would say Vidic but only as i think he has the consistency