What do you think?

[alphavicen]

I'm on the second year with MU and I have made several signings last summer, my team is now the following. What do you think about it?

GK: De Gea, Johnstone
DFR: Arbeloa, Smalling
DFL: Luke Shaw, Fabio, Fabio Santos
DFC: Phil Jones, Álvarez Balanta, Ferdinand, Vidic
DMC: Carrick, Barry
MC: Fellaini, Rakitic, Verratti (on loan), Cleverley
AMR: Valencia, Nani
AML: Young, Marko Marin, Zaha
AMC: Januzaj, Powell, Rooney
ST: Van Persie, Wellbeck

Sold: Rafael (35 M to PSG), Kagawa (15 M to Milan), Evans (12 M to Everton), Fletcher (4 M to Aston Villa) and many other stuff...

 

[alphavicen]

Hum... 138 views and no answers... my team must be LEGEN - wait for it - DARY!!

 

[MANUMAD]

1. Need better cover for De Gea in goal. Johnstone may be decent but for a top team which should be challenging on all fronts you need better.
2. Lose Fabio get a better wb in - Mayke/Telles maybe or go for the absolute top: MATTIA DI SCIGLIO.
3. Lose Rio and Vidic - they re getting old: look at Denswil and Doria or Mangala/Hummels/Subotic/Papadopoulos.
4. Your DMCs are **** lose both. Bring in Vidal or if too exp Gas Gil Romero/Lucas Romero/Reyes
5. Another cf: FACUNDO FERREYRA/TIMO WERNER/MITROVIC

Anyway for the people you sold and being Utd your squad is not that great ...

 

[LedleysKnee]

Would look for another striker, up to you whether you go for one who can deliver results instantly or a young regen/ wonderkid as a long term replacment for RVP.

I disagree with the above poster about the need for a strong back up keeper. So long as De Gea has been performing well (which he should be) I've never needed a back up goalie that much. Not sure how good Johnstone is but as long as he is good enough for a top championship/ lower PL side he should be adequate enough.

I'd keep one of Vidic or Ferdinand but only as 4th/ 5th choices and only if their wages aren't ridiculous.

Oh, me and my mate did a save where he was United. Ryan Guald proved a good player all over the midfield and he had Mario Mandzukic as a striker who was simply fantastic. He won Champions League first season and I don't think he'd have been able to without Mandzukic so might be worth looking into.

 

[Jimbhoy]

ergo sum

 

[jord2009]

to start with you've sold the best RB on the game and replaced him with a Liverpool reject
Carrick and Barry so both will need replacing ASAP should have bought cristane from Milan
Welbeck isn't good enough for a main striker at united so I'd look at using and training james Wilson hes awesome
Hummels & Varane for vidic and Rio and use keane aswell hes a good CB if trained

 

[Fatal548]

GK- Get a better backup for De Gea- you never know if De Gea could get a training injury- it happens, believe me.
RB- Should've got Seamus Coleman- Arbeloa is not good enough for Man utd
CB- Good.
LB- Good.
DMC- Ehhh, fine, for now.
CM- Buy a brick **** house- try get Pogba.
AMR- Sell Nani, buy someone better. Valencia is a solid winger though, so maybe just get young backup or a regen to cover him.
AML- Just bad lol, rehaul this position. Reus, El Shaarawy etc
AMC- Good.
ST- Good.

But, really it depends on your tactic and formation. Post it?