It depends really doing something different with big teams always does well, people say they prefer lower league stories but they never get the views a Man Utd story is going to get, key is to update regularly some people dont want to read a story until they know its going to last as there cant be many stories that get past 5 or 6 posts, dont be disheartened if you dont get hundreds of comments and likes straight away as people want to invest in your story which cant really get going until the second season where we will be able to see the changes you have made, i have done many stories in the past few months and my Man Utd and Man City stories have done the best, some people are well known on this site so get more followers anyway from previous stories so that can also make a difference to views, Also a lot of the more unknown sides in stories seem to do better if the updates are spread out more, Mojodex has had a couple of brilliant stories but that is thanks to knock out a season update almost every day!
Lastly dont do a story because you want views, comments or likes do one that will keep you interest or else your updates will feel like homework
hope this helps a little